Sports / South Africa

A Bok reality check

A Bok reality check

Courtney Jamieson of the @DummySwitchPod examines South Africa's France defeat, selection concerns, missed opportunities and whether the Boks need to adapt.

Courtney Jamieson of the @DummySwitchPod examines South Africa's France defeat, selection concerns, missed opportunities and whether the Boks need to adapt.

Courtney Jamieson of the @DummySwitchPod examines South Africa's France defeat, selection concerns, missed opportunities and whether the Boks need to adapt.

_________________________________________________________________________

Boks vs France… All the underhanded tricks were in play, even if we deny that they come from us. A late front-row change was met by the announcement of Antoine Dupont at 10, but he played 9 the whole time.

A few harsh calls here and there remind you of the rugby that is played now, not the rugby that we knew. Once the ball is at the back of the scrum or somewhat hooked, you can’t coax the penalty at scrum time no matter how justified you are.

The bottom line is that the Boks couldn’t impose themselves on the contest.

READ | Match-fixing or a technology problem? Rassie questions TMO silence on knee-drop tackles in Paris

The concerning part isn't necessarily losing to France, it's how we lost. We pride ourselves on dictating the physical contest and forcing the opposition to play on our terms. When that doesn't happen, what is the alternative? We have enough talent to adapt, but sometimes it feels like we're waiting for the opposition to blink first.

The contestable kicks weren’t so contestable. The rabidness of the defence and line speed was better executed by the French, legally or illegally. Decisions on yellow and red cards also weren’t in our favour. What we might think is soft or reasonable is out of the question now.

Piardi swallowed his whistle at scrum time but it’s not an area to complain about. Rather, it’s one that needs to be adjusted to because a complaining Saffa is the last thing taken seriously.

In terms of selection decisions, it seems the innovation of selecting Jan-Hendrik Wessels as a hybrid hooker/loosehead prop suggests the next evolution is specialisation and just him playing hooker (back to square one, which solves the missing gaps in the Bok squad leading up to the RWC, where we have enough hybrids).

There's also a difference between versatility and being a specialist at international level. We celebrate players who can cover three positions but at some point someone needs to be exceptional at one. Especially in the front row where being competent isn't always enough against the best in the world. Maybe the answer isn't another hybrid, but a proper specialist.

Embedded article image

Jan Hendrik Wessels. (Photo by David Winter/Gallo Images)

Now we meet the harsh truth: some of these individuals are not ready for the big time. Their continued selection this weekend further reinforces that they need to face tough trials until they are ready.

The fight that won the last France vs Boks game at the World Cup wasn’t there against a weakened French side last weekend. It’s funny because we saw the same Bok swipe that looked like a knock-on, but this time it was Hooker, not Etzebeth, and the new generation doesn't have that winning edge. Ultimately, the kick chase wasn’t as effective, the contestables were more contested, and France were more inventive.

We can ignore these realities and label Dupont just a regular player, but we need to face reality and our shortcomings. It seems like the strategy is to continue pushing these players to breaking point where they can’t handle it until they can. We’ll just have to see if that works this weekend and beyond.

And perhaps that's the uncomfortable part of this whole exercise. We know Rassie is prepared to lose games in pursuit of something bigger and history suggests there's method to it. But that doesn't mean every selection is beyond criticism. Trusting the process and questioning the process aren't mutually exclusive. Supporters should be allowed to do both without being accused of disloyalty.

It’s just tricky because we’re so close to the RWC. Lessons need to be learnt fast, but those are the bosses’ decisions and by the majority of Saffa opinions we can't challenge or dispute them. We should just trust in Rassie.

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by KickOff
View on KickOff

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…