Tech / Nigeria

Africa risks driving digital payments back to cash as transaction taxes undermine financial inclusion

Africa risks driving digital payments back to cash as transaction taxes undermine financial inclusion

Africa’s ambition to expand digital payments and bring millions of people into the formal financial system faces a growing policy contradiction, as governments impose taxes on electronic transactions even while investing in payment infrastructure designed to make moving money cheaper.

The contradiction is becoming increasingly visible as countries deploy interoperable payment systems to reduce transaction costs, encourage digital adoption and improve access to financial services, while tax policies risk making electronic payments less attractive, particularly to low-income consumers and small businesses.

Rwanda offers a clear illustration of what shared payment infrastructure can achieve. Since July 14, domestic interoperable retail payments in the country have operated through eKash, an instant payment platform designated by the National Bank of Rwanda and operated through the national switch, RSwitch.

The platform connects existing banks and mobile money providers, allowing customers to transfer money across financial institutions without downloading another application or opening a new account.

Transfers between bank accounts and mobile wallets now cost a flat RWF20, approximately one US cent, irrespective of the amount, up to RWF10 million. The charge replaces a previous pricing structure that could reach RWF5,000, representing a reduction of more than 99 per cent at the upper end.

The development demonstrates how shared infrastructure, rather than competition between individual providers alone, can significantly reduce the cost of digital financial services.

However, while Rwanda is making digital transfers cheaper, other African governments have introduced or maintained levies on electronic transactions, creating additional costs for consumers and businesses.

Ghana introduced an electronic transfer levy in 2022, initially charging 1.5 per cent before reducing it to one per cent. Cameroon has applied a 0.2 per cent tax on transfers and withdrawals since January 2022, while Senegal previously taxed financial transactions directly before replacing the arrangement this year with a levy based on operators’ revenues.

The policy direction has increasingly attracted resistance. Ghana repealed its electronic transfer levy in April 2025, while Kenya’s National Assembly rejected a proposed 16 per cent value-added tax on person-to-person mobile money transfers in June, with 122 lawmakers voting against the proposal and 40 supporting it.

An International Monetary Fund working paper published in December 2025, using transaction-level data from Cameroon, found that transaction levies reduce mobile money usage and encourage consumers to return to cash. The researchers estimated that the efficiency cost was approximately 35 per cent of the revenue raised.

The findings raise questions about whether the immediate revenue governments collect from digital transactions justifies the longer-term economic costs of discouraging their use.

Taxing transactions could reverse inclusion gains

The concern is significant for African economies where mobile money has become an important entry point into formal financial services for people traditionally excluded from conventional banking.

In Rwanda, approximately 96 per cent of adults had access to formal financial services in 2024, compared with 48 per cent in 2008. Mobile wallets accounted for a substantial part of this expansion, with 68.5 per cent of adults using them, while only about five per cent held a traditional bank account.

These figures illustrate why transaction costs matter. For people without convenient access to bank branches, mobile money provides an alternative for receiving payments, transferring funds, paying bills and conducting everyday business.

When governments impose charges on these activities, the additional costs can accumulate, particularly for low-income individuals, informal traders and microbusinesses that depend on frequent, relatively small transactions.

The Kenya Bankers Association raised this concern during deliberations over the proposed tax on mobile money transfers. Its chief executive warned lawmakers in May that taxing digital platforms could push consumers “to the mattress and to the informal economy”, where transactions become difficult for authorities to capture.

The warning highlights a wider economic problem: making digital transactions more expensive could encourage consumers to return to cash, weakening the financial inclusion gains governments are trying to consolidate.

Nigeria’s payment infrastructure offers another lesson

Nigeria provides another example of how shared payment infrastructure can expand digital financial activity.

The Nigeria Inter-Bank Settlement System’s Instant Payment platform processed 11.2 billion transfers in a year, representing a 120 per cent increase compared with 2022, according to NIBSS’s published material. The platform supports near-instant transfers across participating financial institutions, while Nigeria’s total digital payment transaction value reached approximately N1.07 quadrillion.

NIBSS describes its model as a unified, central-bank-backed interoperability switch, demonstrating how shared payment infrastructure can connect financial institutions and facilitate transactions across different networks.

However, the organisation has also highlighted an important challenge: ultra-low transaction fees benefit consumers but can squeeze agent networks, particularly in communities where poor connectivity and unstable electricity increase the cost of providing financial services.

This introduces a difficult balancing act for regulators. Making payments affordable is necessary for inclusion, but the agents and service providers extending financial access must also remain economically viable.

The Enhancing Financial Innovation and Access (EFInA) organisation has similarly identified the high cost of financial services as a barrier to formal financial inclusion in Nigeria.

Its research reinforces the importance of affordability in expanding access, particularly among populations that remain underserved by conventional banking institutions.

For Nigeria, where agent banking and mobile money operators play an important role in extending financial services beyond bank branches, policies that increase transaction costs could undermine efforts to deepen digital participation.

Governments could undermine their own revenue ambitions

Beyond financial inclusion, transaction-based taxation presents a wider challenge for governments seeking to expand their revenue bases.

Digital payment infrastructure creates transaction records that can improve the visibility of economic activity, strengthen monitoring and support more effective tax administration. Cash transactions, by contrast, are generally more difficult for authorities to trace, particularly within large informal economies.

This means encouraging electronic payments can help governments bring previously invisible economic activities into formal financial records.

At the 3i Africa Summit in May, Zakari Mumuni, first deputy governor of the Bank of Ghana, argued that instant payment systems should be treated as critical economic infrastructure.

Mumuni said high transaction costs remained a barrier to digital finance and that governments could derive revenue benefits from payment systems through greater transparency and efficiency.

“The task before us is not invention but scale,” he said.

His position is particularly significant given Ghana’s subsequent repeal of its electronic transfer levy. It reflects a growing policy argument that expanding digital payment adoption could deliver broader economic benefits than collecting revenue from individual transactions.

When authorities impose charges on digital payments, however, some consumers may reconsider their use of electronic channels. The state could collect additional revenue from existing users while discouraging others from entering the formal financial system.

The longer-term risk is that governments weaken the transaction visibility and financial records that could support broader tax compliance.

This does not mean digital payment infrastructure should be exempt from taxation. Rather, it raises the question of whether taxing individual transactions is the most effective way to generate sustainable public revenue.

The policy choice facing Africa

As the Africa Fintech Summit meets in Kigali, Rwanda’s eKash model and Nigeria’s NIBSS experience demonstrate the economic potential of interoperable payment infrastructure.

The infrastructure question is increasingly settled: shared payment rails can reduce costs, connect financial institutions and make digital transactions more accessible.

The unresolved question is whether tax policies will support or undermine that progress.

Ghana’s repeal, Kenya’s rejection of proposed VAT on person-to-person transfers and Senegal’s shift towards taxing operators’ revenues suggest that some governments are reconsidering direct transaction taxation.

For African policymakers, the challenge is to balance revenue generation with affordability, financial inclusion and the sustainability of the businesses supporting digital payments.

Ultimately, the value of payment infrastructure extends beyond how quickly money moves between accounts. It lies in bringing more individuals and businesses into the formal economy, improving transaction visibility and creating opportunities for sustainable economic growth.

If governments make digital payments more expensive, they risk pushing some consumers back towards cash, weakening the very financial inclusion and economic formalisation efforts they have spent years building.

Royal Ibeh

Royal Ibeh is a senior journalist with years of experience reporting on Nigeria’s technology and health sectors. She currently covers the Technology and Health beats for BusinessDay newspaper, where she writes in-depth stories on digital innovation, telecom infrastructure, healthcare systems, and public health policies.

Add BusinessDay as a preferred source on Google Follow BusinessDay on Google News

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by BusinessDay
View on BusinessDay

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…