Business / Nigeria

Apex bank pensioners beg for justice 16 years after supreme court victory — Akanni

Despite winning landmark judgments at the Federal High Court, Court of Appeal and Supreme Court, retired Central Bank of Nigeria workers are still struggling to secure the full implementation of their pension entitlements, raising fresh questions about institutional accountability and respect for the rule of law

For more than two decades, retired workers of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) have been locked in a protracted battle to secure what they insist is their legitimate pension entitlement, despite having obtained favourable judgments from the highest courts in the country.

Their ordeal, which began in 1999, has become a troubling example of how citizens can win legal battles but continue to struggle to enjoy the benefits of justice.

The case dates back to a dispute over the implementation of the Federal Government’s pension harmonisation policy. The affected pensioners approached the Federal High Court in 1999, seeking the enforcement of their rights under the applicable pension arrangements.

On May 22, 2000, the Federal High Court delivered judgment in their favour. 

The decision was subsequently affirmed by the Court of Appeal on December 5, 2006, before the Supreme Court, on May 21, 2010, upheld the favourable decisions in Central Bank of Nigeria v. Amao & Others, Appeal No. SC 168/2007.

The Supreme Court affirmed the pensioners’ entitlement to harmonised pensions calculated in accordance with the applicable Federal Government policy.

Yet, 16 years after the Supreme Court judgment and more than 26 years after the original proceedings commenced, the pensioners are still reportedly struggling to secure full and satisfactory implementation of the decisions

The prolonged dispute has raised fundamental questions about the authority of judicial pronouncements, the obligations of public institutions and the protection of the rights of retired workers.

In a paper titled “Economic Reforms in Nigeria, Workers’ Welfare and the Imperative of Inclusive Governance,” presented at the LAWAN 2026 Annual Conference in Lagos, Professor Tunde Akanni expressed concern over the continuing difficulties confronting the CBN pensioners.

Akanni, a professor of Journalism at the Lagos State University, LASU, described their experience as an important test of Nigeria’s commitment to the rule of law, insisting that favourable court judgments must translate into tangible benefits for those who obtained them.

He questioned how confidence in retirement security could be sustained when pensioners encounter prolonged difficulties in enforcing judicially recognised entitlements.

“How can workers be confident that their pensions constitute secure rewards for years of service when retirees encounter prolonged difficulties enforcing judicially recognised entitlements?” he asked

The professor argued that the plight of the pensioners should not be treated as an isolated institutional disagreement but as a matter of wider public interest, particularly because it concerns the credibility of public institutions and the protection of citizens’ rights.

He observed that pensioners do not emerge from nowhere, stressing that they are products of the workforce and that today’s workers are tomorrow’s retirees.

According to him, “Pensioners do not emerge from nowhere. They are products of the workforce, just as butterflies emerge through successive stages of development. Today’s workers are tomorrow’s retirees.”

He consequently challenged organised labour to broaden its advocacy beyond serving the interests of active workers to include the protection of retired employees, particularly those struggling to enforce their pension rights.

Akanni maintained that labour unions could not genuinely claim to defend workers while abandoning pensioners to prolonged institutional disputes and financial difficulties.

The CBN pensioners’ controversy has also attracted attention because of allegations that enforcement proceedings have been prolonged by successive preliminary objections, resistance to the production of relevant compliance documents and other litigation-related manoeuvres.

The pensioners have reportedly raised concerns about alleged intimidation and punitive treatment associated with their pursuit of judicial remedies.

Although such allegations require fair and independent examination, particularly where related proceedings remain pending, Akanni believes the central issue should not be lost in the prolonged legal contest.

“The fundamental question is straightforward: has the judgment of the highest court been fully complied with?” he asked.

His concern reflects a broader principle that public institutions must be subject to the same laws they are established to administer and enforce.

Akanni warned that where government institutions are perceived to operate above the law, the consequences extend beyond the immediate parties to a dispute.

He identified institutional distrust, avoidable litigation costs, unequal access to justice and the weakening of democratic governance as some of the consequences of disregard for judicial decisions.

According to him, citizens may gradually lose confidence in lawful dispute-resolution mechanisms when they discover that obtaining a favourable judgment does not necessarily guarantee the enjoyment of their rights.

The professor also linked the pensioners’ experience to the broader debate about Nigeria’s economic reforms, arguing that economic progress should not be measured exclusively by government revenue, foreign reserves, exchange rate performance or investor confidence.

Rather, he insisted that the ultimate measure of economic reform should include the quality of life of ordinary citizens, the security of workers and the dignity of retirees.

“A country cannot credibly promote pension security while allowing legitimate disputes involving retirees to linger indefinitely,” he declared.

He further stressed that pension obligations must be treated as binding commitments rather than discretionary expenditure.

In his view, the introduction of a new pension system cannot extinguish obligations arising under previous arrangements, adding that such commitments must be identified, funded and discharged in accordance with applicable laws and judicial decisions.

The professor therefore called for stronger institutional accountability and transparent mechanisms to resolve outstanding pension disputes.

He urged the Federal Government to encourage a transparent, lawful and independently verifiable examination of the issues surrounding the CBN pensioners’ case.

He also called for relevant records to be made available through appropriate legal processes and for every outstanding obligation established by the courts to be discharged without unnecessary delay.

Beyond the immediate dispute, Akanni called on relevant government agencies, labour organisations, civil society groups and oversight institutions to demonstrate greater commitment to protecting the rights of pensioners.

He specifically warned against any suggestion that citizens exercising their constitutional right to approach the courts should be subjected to intimidation or punitive treatment.

Any such allegations, he said, should be independently investigated, with established violations attracting appropriate consequences.

The professor’s intervention also draws relevance from Nobel Laureate Professor Wole Soyinka’s recent criticism of the persistent failure of institutions to implement court judgments.

Speaking at the Nigerian Ombudsman Annual Conference in Abuja on October 15, Soyinka expressed dismay over the disregard for judicial decisions and the distressing situation in which litigants sometimes die without enjoying justice already pronounced in their favour.

Akanni argued that Soyinka’s intervention should resonate particularly with institutions responsible for workers’ and pensioners’ welfare.

He maintained that a court judgment that cannot be enforced diminishes the practical value of justice, while a pension entitlement that cannot be accessed undermines the very purpose of retirement security.

For the affected CBN retirees, the issue goes beyond legal arguments and institutional procedures. It concerns their ability to enjoy the financial security they believe they earned through years of service.

“The pensioners deserve more than expressions of sympathy. They deserve justice, dignity and the opportunity to enjoy the fruits of their years of service,” Akanni declared.

He urged the Federal Government to treat the matter as an opportunity to demonstrate that no public institution is above the law and that judicial authority must be respected regardless of the identity or institutional status of the parties involved.

As the dispute continues to attract attention, the CBN pensioners’ experience raises an uncomfortable question about the value of judicial victories in Nigeria: what does it mean to win at the Supreme Court if the benefits of that victory remain difficult to obtain?

For pensioners who have spent years seeking the implementation of judgments in their favour, the demand is neither extraordinary nor unreasonable. It is simply that the justice already pronounced by the courts should translate into practical reality.

After 26 years of waiting, their struggle has become more than a pension dispute. It is a test of Nigeria’s commitment to the rule of law, institutional accountability and the dignity of its senior citizens.

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by Vanguard
View on Vanguard

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…