By Juliet Umeh
The New Nigeria Peoples Party, NNPP, has described it as “unwarranted and inappropriate” comments blaming President Bola Tinubu and the Presidency for a court judgment that nullified the leadership of the African Democratic Congress, ADC, and invalidated decisions taken under it.
The party said those who instituted the case were Nigerians with the same right as others to participate in the 2027 general elections.
The NNPP’s position was contained in a statement on Monday by its Board of Trustees Chairman and founder, Dr Boniface Aniebonam.
Aniebonam urged Nigerians to examine the judgment without political bias, saying an outcome with political consequences was not, by itself, evidence of executive interference.
“I have followed with considerable interest the growing commentaries on the recent judgment of the Federal High Court,” he said.
“There is an unfortunate tendency in our public discourse to judge judicial decisions principally by their political consequences. When a judgment favours one political interest, the judge is praised for courage. When it produces an unfavourable outcome, the same judge may suddenly be portrayed as an instrument of an unseen political agenda.
“That is not a sound basis for evaluating the administration of justice.”
The Federal High Court in Abuja, on November 5, nullified the leadership of the ADC led by former Senate President, David Mark, and invalidated decisions taken under it, including the party’s presidential primary that produced former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar as its candidate for the 2027 elections.
Justice Peter Lifu held that the Mark-led Caretaker Committee was illegal and nullified the process through which it conducted the primary. The court also invalidated the emergence of former Interior Minister, Rauf Aregbesola, as National Secretary, other national officers’ appointments and the party’s nominations for the elections.
The judgment followed a suit filed by former ADC Deputy National Chairman (North-East), Nafiu Bala Gombe, who challenged the process through which Mark and other caretaker committee members assumed control of the party.
Aniebonam said the fact that a judgment affected a prominent aspirant’s political prospects did not establish that the Presidency had engineered it.
“An outcome that affects the political fortunes of a prominent aspirant does not provide any material evidence that the Presidency engineered it,” he said.
“If there is evidence of executive interference or judicial compromise, it should be presented and subjected to appropriate scrutiny. But political suspicion must not be elevated into established fact simply because respected commentators repeat it.”
He added: “There is a fundamental distinction between questioning the reasoning of a judgment and questioning the integrity of the judicial officer who delivered it. The former is legitimate legal criticism; the latter requires credible evidence.”
The NNPP founder advised the ADC leadership to pursue its legal options, including an appeal to the Supreme Court or an application for a stay of execution.
He said the NNPP had also faced a prolonged legal dispute over its leadership but did not blame the Presidency.
“We fought until INEC obeyed court orders and recognised our genuine leadership,” he said.
“In all political parties, some people will always feel aggrieved after internal primaries. The onus is on leadership to find ways to resolve their internal crisis and, if possible, stop the matter from going to litigation.
“Once the matter goes to court, it can go either way. We must learn to remain broad-minded on these issues and not always look for the ‘fall guy’.”
Aniebonam also cautioned the media against providing space for inflammatory statements that could provoke negative reactions among Nigerians and damage the country’s image internationally.
“We should try to limit the way we portray the nation, as it has so much affected us globally. Each judgment delivered in Nigeria has those it did not favour calling out the judiciary,” he said.
He urged political leaders and Nigerians to guard their utterances and prioritise national unity and peace ahead of the 2027 elections.
“It is my hope that all concerned shall be more constructive in their utterances and discussions of issues, rather than resorting to individual attacks,” Aniebonam added.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.