Politics / Nigeria

Benue South APC Primary: Collation Officer petitions Police over disputed result

Benue South APC Primary: Collation Officer petitions Police over disputed result

…matter is subject to determination of court – Alapa

The Collation Officer for the May 18, 2026, All Progressives Congress (APC) Benue South Senatorial District primary election, Dr. Peter Sani Ochijele, has petitioned the Commissioner of Police in Benue State over a disputed result sheet reportedly presented in court by one of the aspirants, Hon. Nelson Godwin Onyilokwu Alapa.

Ochijele, through his solicitors, Paul E. Ikwe, Esq., and Jeremiah O. Adoga, Esq., is seeking a police investigation into the circumstances surrounding the document, which he says bears a signature attributed to him that he does not recognise.

In the petition dated September 30, 2026, and addressed to the Commissioner of Police in Makurdi, Ochijele stated that six aspirants participated in the primary election, with results from the nine local government areas collated at the senatorial headquarters at Lux Haven Hotel, Otukpo.

According to the petition, results submitted by the nine local government area collation officers were collated and announced by Ochijele at the conclusion of the exercise.

The petition stated that the National Assembly Primary Election Collation Officer, Alhaji Sabiu Saidu Mahuta, subsequently announced Dr. Francis Ottah Agbo as the winner and returned him elected with 58,760 votes.

Other candidates recorded the following scores: Hon. Joseph Ojobo, 6,782 votes; Hon. Gabriel Oloche Agidani, 5,246; Hon. Dan Onje, 4,570; Alapa, 4,312; and Hon. Patrick Idoko Ojechema, 2,732 votes.

Ochijele said the results were announced in the presence of party members, security personnel, agents of the aspirants and officials of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), who monitored the exercise.

He further stated that the result sheet was signed by the relevant officials, including himself, Mahuta and his secretary, Dr. Bashir Garba, before copies were distributed to the aspirants’ agents, INEC and other relevant bodies.

However, Ochijele said he later became aware of a suit instituted by Alapa at the Federal High Court, Abuja, with Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1092/2026, challenging the outcome of the primary election.

According to the petition, a different result sheet was presented in connection with the court proceedings, purportedly showing that Alapa had emerged as the winner of the primary.

The disputed document reportedly credited Alapa with 24,788 votes.

Ochijele maintained that the document did not reflect the results he collated and announced during the exercise. He also stated that his role was limited to collating and announcing the results, while the authority to declare the winner and return him elected rested with Mahuta and his team.

In the petition, his lawyers stated: “Our client wishes to state categorically that the result which Hon. Nelson Godwin Onyilokwu Alapa has paraded in the processes filed in the court purporting himself to be the winner of the Benue South APC Senatorial Primary election did not originate or emanate from the election which our client was the Collation Agent.”

They added that Ochijele disputed the signature attributed to him on the document, stating that he did not sign the result sheet in question.

When contacted, Chief Alapa said: “It is unfortunate. I woke up to this news, and the matter is sub judice. The matter in question is in court. So it would be wrong for any of us to be peddling one thing or the other. He has closed his case. Ochijele came as a witness for the second defendant and gave his statement. 

“Whatever document he is claiming or asserting, whatever position to, he made them in court and presented his own position. So it would be wrong for me to make a statement in the matter that is in court in Nigeria. 

“As a citizen of this country, as a former lawmaker with experience in law, we should allow the court to exhaust the window, either in my favour or in their favour. It does not matter. Then we can now start analysing what went wrong or what did not work. I do not know why he decided to petition the Commissioner of Police. It is unfortunate. 

“I was a candidate in that election. So I would be surprised for Ochijele to say that I falsified whatever, according to him. I am to be voted for by the electorate. I am not a member of his committee. But all of that, of course, is subject to the determination of the court and then we shall see who went wrong. And then we can now go the other way, of course, after the matter. I am only just saying that it is not proper for us to discuss an issue that is in the court’s competent jurisdiction.” 

Asked if he would present himself if summoned by the Commissioner of Police, Chief Alapa said, “Of course, if the CP invites me, why not? As a citizen of this country, if anybody alleges anything against you, why not? 

“I am just saying that it is premature to start talking. This matter has been going on in court, and he has gone there to present himself, gave his evidence and everything. All of a sudden, you just woke up to petition on social media. I am silent because, as a citizen of this country, I know what the law says. So, I submit myself to whatever the court will say. Then we can go to whatever allegation is laid.”

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by Vanguard
View on Vanguard

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…