
Anticipation is high that the Carling Cup will have its first final involving two of the Big Three clubs since 2015. Photo: Anesh Dekiby/Gallo Images
The Big Three will be back in domestic cup finals conversations this weekend as they all stand a chance of getting into the Carling Knockout trophy decider.
Orlando Pirates return to Moses Mabhida Stadium to play Stellenbosch on Saturday before Mamelodi Sundowns host Kaizer Chiefs at Loftus Versfeld the next day.
Whatever happens at least one of the Big Three – Pirates, Chiefs, or Sundowns – will be in the final currently scheduled for December 12 but whose date will be moved if the Brazilians are in it.
Big Three in line for final
READ | Bafana’s qualification route demands and calculations
For the sponsors and most football followers their hopes will be on having two of the Big Three in that final.
That will be Pirates against either Chiefs or Sundowns.
Not since Carling took over as sponsors have they had two of the Big Three in a final.
A final involving two of the Big Three in this competition was last played in 2010 – one of four occasions that two of the Big Three have been in a final through the PSL era years.
KickOff has profiled the three giants’ history in domestic knockout competitions and Pirates have played in the most finals while Chiefs enjoy the bigger success slice.
Pirates – 15/29
The Bucs have won 15 out of 29 finals and are the holders of the Carling Cup. They last participated in a final as recent as October being the 2026 MTN8 final where they lost to to Sundowns by 2-0.
They reach cup finals more often than any other PSL club, but their success rate stands at 51.7%.
Pirates’ first PSL era trophy was won on November 23, 1996, in the BOB Save Super Bowl won courtesy of Andries Sebola’s solitary goal against Jomo Cosmos.
Sundowns – 11/26
The Brazilians have reached 26 domestic cup finals since their first in 1997 when they lost the Rothmans Cup final to Kaizer Chiefs on penalties.
Their first PSL-era cup triumph was the 1998 Bob Save Super Bowl, when they beat Orlando Pirates on penalties after two 1-1 matches.
That final against Pirates couldn't produce a winner after extra-time and the same happened in the replay, which Sundowns ultimately won 6-5 on penalties.
From their count of 26 to date, the Chloorkop-based club has won 11 with the most recent being the 2026 MTN8.
They win 42% of finals.
Chiefs – 16/23
Whenever Amakhosi get into a final they always have a better chance of lifting the trophy having won 16 out of 23 cup finals.
Their most recent success was the 2025 Nedbank Cup which came after 11 years of waiting.
READ| PSL hitman lights up international stage
Prior to that they had last won a domestic cup in September 2014 when they edged Orlando Pirates in the MTN8 final.
Their first cup success in the PSL era years was the 1997 Rothmans Cup. Their cup final success rate is 70%.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.