Sports / South Africa

Chiefs Hold The Edge Over Sundowns

Chiefs Hold The Edge Over Sundowns

Chiefs Hold The Edge Over Sundowns

(Photo by Sydney Seshibedi/Gallo Images)

Kaizer Chiefs may have history on their side when they meet Mamelodi Sundowns in the Carling Knockout Cup semi-final, but recent results suggest that Amakhosi will have to overcome a difficult opponent if they are to reach the final.

The two sides meet at Loftus Versfeld Stadium on Sunday, 22 November, with kick-off scheduled for 15h30. It will be the 10th time they have faced each other in the competition, dating back to their first encounter in 1983, when Chiefs went on to lift their first League Cup title.

Check Out: Proving Broos Wrong? Rele Breaks Silence

Amakhosi Boast the Better Head-to-Head Record

Looking at the historical record, Chiefs have enjoyed considerably more success in this particular competition. Of their nine previous meetings, Amakhosi have won six, although three of those victories came through penalty shootouts. Sundowns, meanwhile, have recorded two victories, with one match ending in a draw before Chiefs eventually prevailed in a replay.

The numbers give Chiefs an interesting psychological advantage heading into Sunday's encounter, particularly considering their success in the competition's biggest matches.

But Sundowns Have the Recent Momentum

However, the most recent history between the two clubs tells a different story. Sundowns have won the last two meetings in the Carling Knockout, beating Chiefs 3-1 in the 2015/16 final before handing them a heavy 4-0 defeat in the quarter-finals of the 2024/25 campaign.

That 4-0 Thrashing

That latter result remains particularly significant, as it was the biggest winning margin recorded in their nine previous encounters in the competition. Peter Shalulile, Iqraam Rayners and Khuliso Mudau were among the players who helped Masandawana produce a dominant display, with Rayners scoring twice, including from the penalty spot.

Chiefs' Penalty Shootout Dominance

One of the most interesting aspects of this rivalry has been Chiefs' ability to deliver when matches have gone beyond regulation time.

Amakhosi have won three of their previous encounters against Sundowns on penalties, all in finals. The first came in the 1997/98 campaign, when the sides drew 1-1 before a replay also ended 1-1, with Chiefs eventually winning 3-2 in the shootout.

They repeated the feat in the 1998/99 final, winning 2-1 on penalties after a 2-2 draw, before another shootout triumph in the 2007/08 final. That occasion saw Itumeleng Khune emerge as the hero against his mentor, Brian Baloyi, in what was famously billed as a battle between Spider Kid and Spider Man.

Chiefs also have three outright victories in the competition, having beaten Sundowns 2-0 in 1983, 1-0 in 1986 and 1-0 in the 2009/10 quarter-finals, when Mandla Masango scored the decisive goal.

Sundowns, on the other hand, have two outright victories, both coming in more recent years. Their 2015/16 final victory was followed by the emphatic quarter-final win in 2024/25.

The Bigger Cup Rivalry

Beyond the Carling Knockout, the overall cup record between the two clubs also favours Chiefs.

According to the supplied head-to-head figures, this will be their 34th meeting across cup competitions. Amakhosi have recorded 14 victories in regulation time and another six on penalties, giving them 20 victories in total. Sundowns have eight regulation-time wins and two penalty shootout victories, while three encounters have ended in draws.

Their most recent cup meeting outside the Carling Knockout came in the 2024/25 Nedbank Cup semi-final. Sundowns initially took the lead, but Chiefs fought back to secure a 2-1 victory and book their place in the final.

That result is a reminder that Chiefs have been capable of upsetting Sundowns in knockout football, even when the Brazilians have enjoyed the advantage in recent league and cup encounters.

Who Has The Upper Hand?

On historical numbers alone, Chiefs have the advantage heading into Sunday's semi-final. They have won more of the previous Carling Knockout encounters, boast a superior overall cup record against Sundowns and have demonstrated an ability to win high-pressure matches, particularly in penalty shootouts.

However, Sundowns have a strong argument based on recent form in this particular competition. They have won the last two Carling Knockout meetings, scoring seven goals and conceding just one across those matches.

The historical advantage belongs to Chiefs, but the recent trend favours Sundowns. With a place in the final at stake, Amakhosi will need to draw on their impressive cup history against Masandawana, while the Brazilians will be looking to extend their recent dominance in the competition.

Check Out: All The Teams Who've Qualified For AFCON So Far

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by Soccer Laduma
View on Soccer Laduma

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…