Sports / South Africa

Clear and obvious… Convenient interpretations

Clear and obvious… Convenient interpretations

Christopher Nkomo of the @DummySwitchPod takes hard look at the Springboks' loss to France.

Christopher Nkomo of the @DummySwitchPod takes hard look at the Springboks' loss to France.

Christopher Nkomo of the @DummySwitchPod takes hard look at the Springboks' loss to France, questioning their attacking variation, scrum dominance, officiating and ability to find solutions.

_________________________________________________________________________________

As they say and as we obviously know, a week is a long time in rugby and in anything for that matter! After the high of the Italy result, the Boks' latest outing has certainly burst our bubble. Credit must go to the French who were determined to finally get this one by hook or by crook.

The Boks have an incredible forward platform but on Friday night there was a steely determination, almost desperation, from the French to match their physicality and bring their own dose of defensive line speed to blunt the Bok backline, which had a day to forget in attack. Early in the contest, things were a little loose, and the Boks showed signs that they could potentially neutralise the French with ball in hand. But the execution wasn't there. That allowed France to grow into the game, build pressure and produce two well-orchestrated tries, along with a bizarre and rare 'falcon' try.

READ | Rassie slapped with six-match ban as SA Rugby seeks hearing

Make no mistake, the Boks were nowhere near the same level as the week before. Perhaps one of the drawbacks of the way they play and reportedly train, where the intensity is said to be tougher than an actual game, is that consistently replicating those performances is not simply a matter of switching on and off. This is where we would expect to see a variation in approach, particularly when Plan A isn't paying off. In a game that was once again overshadowed by officiating controversy at scrum time and other areas, the Boks struggled at times with the speed and tempo of the French attack and defensively looked to be hanging on by a thread.

The second half was a significant improvement and after throwing every available kitchen sink at the French, a great escape seemed to be on the cards. But through a combination of factors, the Boks ultimately fell agonisingly short. That leaves us with a question worth asking: what is the plan when an opposition team can match our physicality and defensive line speed?

Where is the variation? Where are the alternative attacking shapes? Can we manipulate defensive lines rather than simply trying to run through them?

Embedded article image

Dejection for Jesse Kriel of South Africa following the Nations Championship match against France. (Photo by David Winter/Gallo Images)

With the platform provided by the pack, it would be refreshing to see more of the other side of the Boks, a team prepared to back its athletic ability and launch attacks from different situations, particularly when playing with scrum penalty advantage, i.e. Tony Ball. Too often there seemed to be a lack of cohesion with juggled or inaccurate passes and a backline unable to find that cutting edge to break defensive lines. Winning the physical battle is one thing; knowing what to do with the advantage it creates is another.

Speaking of platforms, what exactly is the reward for dominance? At the core of the Springboks' identity is physical superiority and more specifically, a powerful scrum. But what happens when that dominance doesn't translate into meaningful attacking opportunities? And what happens when the interpretation of who is infringing at scrum time appears to be clearly and obviously ignored?

Do we reward teams for wanting to contest the scrum, or are we gradually turning one of rugby's great contests into a means of simply restarting the game because other teams are unable to consistently challenge the Boks in that department?

This brings us back to the wider officiating debate and the controversy surrounding Rassie's suspension. There is a legitimate conversation to be had about how referees are held accountable, how decisions are scrutinised and where the line should be drawn. Of course, there must be accountability for what is said, but that should not mean that legitimate questions about the consistency of decisions and the application of the laws are simply brushed aside, especially when a mandate has been issued.

The Boks cannot control every interpretation of the laws, every refereeing decision or every opposition defensive strategy. They can, however, control how they respond.

READ | Ireland warned: Rassie "might make some changes" again

Perhaps the most obvious thing the Boks can do is take as much of the game as possible out of the officials' hands. That means looking beyond physical dominance, trusting the attacking weapons at their disposal and finding different ways to unlock opposition defences. We can debate interpretations all week, but the Boks still need to find answers when it is obvious that the scrum dominance won’t be rewarded, and perhaps that is the clearest lesson from Friday night: dominance alone is not always enough. The Boks need more than a powerful platform. They need the variation, precision and attacking imagination to make that platform count.

Questions about inconsistent interpretations should indeed be asked, but those questions must not become a substitute for finding solutions on the field. The Boks cannot control the whistle, but they can control how they respond to it.

Courtney Jameson and Chris Nkomo run the @dummyswitchpod. and are part of KickOff's Bomb Squad and Tap 'n Go team. Be sure to follow them on X.

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by KickOff
View on KickOff

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…