Sports / South Africa

Did Rassie go too far? Former Boks have their say

Did Rassie go too far? Former Boks have their say

Former Springbok greats have entered the fray, delivering sharp verdicts on the Rassie Erasmus saga currently dominating world rugby.

While many in the rugby fraternity acknowledge that Erasmus crossed a line, Springbok legends Corné Krige, Breyton Paulse, and Naas Botha have all questioned the severity of the punishment and the lack of due process, arguing that coaches should be allowed to raise legitimate concerns about officiating.

READ | Rassie was right: Prendergast cleared to face the Boks

It was evident that Erasmus was a frustrated man at the post-match press conference after his side’s 21-19 loss to France in their Nations Championship clash on Saturday.

Perhaps he was more agitated as he answered questions, but he has always gone out of his way to give his best insights into the issues being raised.

By Monday afternoon, perhaps that frustration had got the better of him… or he knew exactly what he wanted to do.

Only Rassie can answer that.

It started with a question about whether Erasmus expected Irish flyhalf Sam Prendergast to play, as it was rumoured at the time that he would be cited for a hip-drop tackle against Fiji.

Erasmus predicted that if he was cited, he would get off on a technicality, before moving on to the French match and highlighting 17 knee-drop tackles that he felt referee Andrea Piardi and his officiating team had missed.

But Erasmus overstepped the mark in World Rugby’s eyes by using the words “match-fixing”.

“There are 17 knee-drop tackles, and the TMO doesn’t come in once.

“I’m not saying he’s wrong; I’m saying if he didn’t see it, it must be a technology problem. If he saw it and decided not to act on it, is that not match-fixing? Is that not interfering with the outcome of a game if you see this injury that happened there, a knee-drop tackle happened there, and it’s been decided that knee-drop tackles are out."

As we all know, he’s been slapped with a six-match ban, with SA Rugby requesting a full misconduct hearing for Erasmus.

So, did Erasmus go about this the right way?

Let’s first look at just how coaches can bring up any potential issues they have with World Rugby, because the process has changed this year.

Before, coaches could send in clips of issues they wanted answers to, while there would also be a pre-match meeting between both teams and the referee.

From this year, however, they can only send in five clips for clarification, while both coaches have to agree to a pre-match meeting with the referee, which is something that doesn’t seem to happen very often.

Both of these new procedures are things Erasmus has expressed his frustration with before.

Former Springbok captain Corné Krige says that Erasmus is speaking for many people when he makes his frustrations clear, including other coaches.

"There are protocols in World Rugby, and he obviously breached those circumstances and the protocols,” Krige told KickOff Rugby.

“The ban is the ban, but I think when he speaks he becomes passionate; he speaks for a lot of people who are also frustrated at the system, but they are too scared to say a word. So I think the other coaches are grateful for Rassie for actually saying what needs to be said at times.”

Krige agreed that the ban was harsh, but that Erasmus had little he could do after breaching World Rugby’s protocols.

Embedded article image

Breyton Paulse. (Gallo Images)

Former Bok winger Breyton Paulse also felt the punishment was severe and, like Krige, agreed that World Rugby protocols needed to be followed. “I think it's a bit harsh, but if those are the protocols, he needs to stick to them,” Paulse said.

"I think Rassie was very frustrated after the French game, and you could see he wasn't very happy or too calm in his press conference [after the match]."

“I just feel he asked questions; he didn't intend to say there was match fixing, in my opinion."

Paulse says the ban imposed by World Rugby, without the chance for Erasmus to defend himself, is wrong.

"Why can't the man defend himself in a hearing? You can't just go the next day and ban the man for six matches. From that point of view, I feel it's very unfair,” Paulse said.

"We all have to respect the game, and the integrity of the game, but if somebody oversteps the line, there needs to be fair processes as well, and I just felt Rassie has been hard done by here.”

WATCH | Knee-drop tackles galore. Clearly Rassie has a point

Naas Botha, speaking on the Drop In podcast, said that while he sympathised with officials, who have to deal with hundreds of rules and interpretations, they shouldn't be untouchable.

"Nobody is complaining because South Africa lost the game. France beat us on the day. That’s the end of it,” Botha said.

“What we’re saying is that if any coach asks a question, you have to address why they can’t question the officials who handled the game.

“You can’t tell me they’re totally untouchable.”

Botha says that by Erasmus highlighting things that happen in matches, he should have the right to ask questions.

“Everybody has a bone to pick with Rassie because they call him out all the time on these laws and the things he does. But he’s not breaking any laws or rules by doing what he’s doing.

“He’s well within his rights to do everything he does, and he’s also within his rights to ask questions.”

READ | Who coaches the Boks while Rassie Erasmus is banned?

Of course, while there’s plenty of support in South Africa for the man who’s transformed rugby in the country, the opposite is true outside its borders, and particularly in the United Kingdom.

The thing is, no matter what side of the fence you sit on, there’s no denying that Erasmus gets eyes on the game, either through his teams winning or by challenging the establishment when he thinks it necessary.

Love him or hate him, it’s hard to ignore him.

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by KickOff
View on KickOff

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…