Health / Nigeria

Experts assess risks of herbal cancer treatments

In the past decade, there has been a rising cancer burden in Nigeria, with a particularly concerning surge in early-onset cancer cases among young adults and adolescents.

Cancer is a generic term for a large group of diseases that can affect any part of the body. Other terms used are malignant tumours and neoplasms.

One defining feature of cancer is the rapid creation of abnormal cells that grow beyond their usual boundaries and which can then invade adjoining parts of the body and spread to other organs.

The European Society of Preventive Medicine explains that the transformation of normal cells into tumour cells is the result of the interaction between a person’s genetic factors and three categories of external agents.

These agents include physical carcinogens, such as ultraviolet and ionising radiation; chemical carcinogens, such as asbestos, components of tobacco smoke, alcohol, aflatoxin (a food contaminant), and arsenic (a drinking water contaminant); and biological carcinogens, such as infections from certain viruses, bacteria, or parasites.

The spread of these abnormal cells is a process known as metastasis. Health experts agree that widespread metastases are the primary cause of death from cancer.

Cancer is a leading cause of death globally, accounting for an estimated 9.8 million to 10 million deaths per year (roughly one in every six deaths), according to data from the World Health Organisation and the International Agency for Research on Cancer.

The WHO noted that nearly a quarter of all cancer deaths are tied directly to five modifiable behavioural and dietary risks: tobacco use, alcohol consumption, high body mass index, low fruit and vegetable intake, and lack of physical activity.

 

Herbal and miraculous claims

When Imelda Idiowa (not her real name) found a strange growth on her breast in 2024, the first person she told was her physician friend, who worked in a state hospital in Ibadan, Oyo State.

Her friend recommended a herbal concoction for her, which promised to cure all forms of growths, masses or lumps on the breast, as well as eradicate cancer.

“My friend told me that the herb would work for me, and that it is made purely from roots and barks, and it has been tested on many cancer patients and they were cured. It was stored in a big keg, which I was drinking from for more than a year.

“Now, look at it, the lump grew into becoming cancerous, and when the pain became unbearable, I went to the hospital, and they said it had gone too bad,” Idiowa told Sunday PUNCH.

Idiowa’s experience was similar to that of Patricia in Lagos State, who had noticed some lumps on her breasts but did not seek medical help.

“I was told that it was a spiritual arrow and that it wasn’t a hospital case. I fasted, went for deliverance, prayed, was prayed for as well, and received my healing by faith, but things didn’t improve. Now, it has become a serious matter, and the place is bad.

“My family and I are currently soliciting donations for surgery. The doctors said I delayed in coming to the hospital and the surgery is urgent. But even then, where would we have got the money for treatment?” Patricia queried.

Recounting what led to his father’s death, a Lagos-based engineer, Toriola, said, “My father wasn’t diagnosed with prostate cancer on time. We spent so much on him, going from place to place and even on his medications.

“When the medications were not working, we resorted to herbal remedies, and we were also consulting seers, clerics and healing homes. When there was no improvement, he was taken back to a federal hospital. By then, he had started bleeding and fell into unconsciousness till he died,” he said.

In Nigeria, the belief in herbal and miraculous cures cuts across the spectrum. Whether in the North, which is predominantly Muslim, the South, which is majority Christian, or among practitioners of marginal religions, there is a belief that “cancer is not for the hospital.”

Others believe it is caused by mystical or spiritual forces or diabolic witchcraft. With such underlying beliefs, many cancer patients resort to seeking spiritual healers instead of hospitals, leading to what health experts describe as late-stage diagnosis, higher mortality, and preventable deaths from cancers and other serious diseases.

Although there is currently no scientific evidence that any herbal remedy can completely cure cancer, Nigerian social media platforms are dotted with various herb vendors who claim to cure cancers from stage one to four.

Two months ago, when the family of the late actor, Taiwo Hassan (Ogogo), disclosed that he had cancer, several individuals publicly promised and delivered litres of herbal concoction (among other religious preparations) to his hospital ward in Lagos.

An unnamed traditional herbal practitioner publicly revealed that an American-based individual offered him N10m to treat the actor, an offer he declined.

Numerous other social media commenters, alternative healers and traditional medicine figures reached out or claimed to have remedies to cure stage 4 cancer.

On his X account, a pharmacist, Saleh Maidoki, said he had sat with families who arrived at the hospital after six months of using “herbs that shrink tumours” and having a lump massaged.

He added, “By then, the conversation had already changed from cure to damage control. In Nigeria, we still lose too many people not because science has nothing to offer, but because we present late.”

Commenting on the potential dangers of trusting herbal vendors for cancer treatment, an oncology researcher and Executive Director of Project PINK BLUE, Abuja, Dr Runcie Chidebe, said that patients waste their lives, scarce resources, time and hope on products, procedures and claims that are hopeless, lack evidence, and cause harm to the patients and their families.

“As a cancer patient advocate for over 10 years, I have seen many patients who use those herbal vendors after their early cancer diagnosis, and when they realised that it does not work and they return to the hospital; sadly, at these times their cancers are now in late stages, that is when the cancers are not curable,” he told Sunday PUNCH.

Chidebe further blamed the government for failing Nigerians by institutionalising the worst, prohibitive and financially toxic healthcare system, adding that the government and the weak public sector system have bred cancer patients who believe herbal claims without evidence.

“Many cancer patients who use herbal medicines use them because of poverty, the cost of hospital care, and how complicated our public hospitals are today. The government is nonchalant about mass health education, failing to adequately inform and educate the Nigerian population on critical health issues.

“The government also has weak policies for health misinformation, and where they exist, there is no enforcement. It’s so sad. We live in a country where if you criticise the government on social media, you might be arrested in hours, but those peddling health misinformation that put millions at risk of death are going about verifying their social accounts with no consequences.

“We grow up seeing ministers of information as mass educators, but today, these officials are political defenders of the government. We grow up seeing the National Orientation Agency using local music songs to educate Nigerians on television and radio; today, we hardly see that NOA leading in mass education,” Chidebe added.

He also called on the Federal Ministry of Health and Communication to implement strict advertising policies and enforcement on health misinformation.

 

Blending faith with alternative therapies

Several high-profile Nigerian pastors have recently shared testimonies regarding being healed from cancer or healing someone of cancer, although some of them admitted that it was a blend of faith, intensive medical treatments and miracles.

In an interview with Sunday PUNCH, a professor at Covenant University and adjunct director of research at Marcelle Ruth Cancer Centre, Lagos, Solomon Rotimi, noted that when someone is diagnosed with cancer, fear and uncertainty can make even the most extraordinary promise of a cure attractive.

He pointed out that in Nigeria, high treatment costs, delayed diagnosis, limited access to care and the perception that cancer is a death sentence make the populace generally vulnerable to such promises with high hopes.

“But claims of miraculous or herbal cancer cures are not new and should not be outrightly discounted. Interestingly, some established anticancer medicines, like paclitaxel and vincristine, originated from plants.

“In effect, they are ‘herbal remedies.’ This demonstrates nature’s medicinal potential, but it doesn’t validate every herbal remedy. What distinguishes an effective treatment from an unproven claim is rigorous scientific evidence of safety and effectiveness.

“Anyone can claim to cure cancer, and such a claim could arise from circumstantial or anecdotal events. Hence, in the scientific process, personal testimonies alone do not establish that a treatment works. Faith, on the other hand, is deeply personal and lies in the realm of spirituality. Science cannot adjudicate every dimension of religious experience,” Rotimi explained.

The professor of clinical biochemistry clarified that what is important to note is that seeking medical treatment is not a rejection of any known faith, adding that taking appropriate action is well recognised as a step of faith.

“Evidence-based cancer care offers physical interventions and actions whose benefits and risks have been systematically investigated. On this note, it is important for the scientific and medical community to intentionally earn public trust.

“When people repeatedly witness cancer patients dying after hospital treatment, without understanding the effects of late diagnosis and the nuances of medical intervention, they may conclude that medicine doesn’t work. We must counter this narrative by sharing authentic stories of cancer survivors, improving science communication, and demonstrating that timely treatment can save lives.

“Ultimately, the Nigerian government must make cancer care affordable, accessible and compassionate. Ultimately, faith and medical treatment need not compete because we deserve both the freedom to believe and access to treatments supported by credible evidence,” Rotimi added.

Also speaking with Sunday PUNCH, a physician at a federal government teaching hospital, Dr Goodness Oghotomo described the growing reliance on herbal remedies and miraculous healing claims among cancer patients as “a serious public health concern.”

He noted that some herbal vendors claim their products cure every type of cancer, including stage IV disease, while certain religious groups encourage patients to reject medical diagnosis and treatment in favour of prayer, holy water or anointing oil.

“One major danger is delayed treatment. Cancer may progress while patients rely on unproven remedies, potentially losing opportunities for curative treatment. Even stage IV cancers may respond to treatment, improving survival and quality of life. Abandoning evidence-based care can therefore have devastating consequences.

“Secondly, some herbal preparations may contain harmful substances, cause liver or kidney damage, or interact with anticancer medications. Patients may also experience financial exploitation, malnutrition and psychological distress when promised cures fail.

“Addressing this problem requires public education and stronger regulation. Governments and regulatory agencies, such as Nigeria’s National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control, should monitor misleading advertisements and investigate products marketed with unsupported cancer-cure claims,” Oghotomo said.

He further urged healthcare professionals to “educate patients about treatment benefits and risks without dismissing their cultural or religious beliefs,” adding that religious and community leaders should encourage patients to combine spiritual support with appropriate medical care rather than abandon treatment.

“Furthermore, improving access to affordable cancer diagnosis and treatment may reduce dependence on questionable alternatives. Ultimately, patients should not have to choose between faith and evidence-based medicine.

“Prayer and spiritual support may provide comfort, but unproven remedies should never replace effective cancer treatment. Patients deserve compassion, honest information and protection from individuals who exploit their vulnerability and hope for recovery,” Oghotomo added.

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by Punch
View on Punch

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…