Africa / Kenya

High Court Issues Ruling on Parents Who Leave Family Land to One Child

High Court Issues Ruling on Parents Who Leave Family Land to One Child

The High Court has ruled that a will remains valid even if a parent left all their family land to one sibling, ruling that other siblings cannot claim a share of the land.

In a ruling on Thursday, November 19, the High Court in Nairobi ruled that other siblings cannot just contest a share of a family land when the will clearly states that it has been left to a particular sibling.

The case arose after three children and a granddaughter of a deceased person went to court, contesting the validity of a will that left a family land under the care of her daughter.

The deceased appointed the daughter as executor of the Will, meaning she was responsible for administering the estate.

A collage of property on sale

Kenyans.co.ke

According to documents before the court, the complainants argued that their mother had not properly signed or thumbprinted the will, and that she was elderly and unwell and may not have been mentally capable of making the Will.

They also argued that the will unfairly excluded other children, raising concerns that their sister might have influenced their mother into leaving her the land.

However, in its ruling, the court found that the claimants did not produce medical records or other convincing evidence demonstrating that she lacked the mental capacity to make a Will on January 19, 2000.

The court therefore found that she was presumed to have been of sound mind.

Further, the court noted that the daughter was not present when her mother gave the instructions or executed the Will.

It therefore found insufficient evidence that the daughter had pressured or manipulated her mother.

"Having considered the evidence, the parties' respective cases and the applicable law, I have found that the Will dated 19th January 2000 was duly executed in accordance with Section 11 of the Law of Succession Act. I have further found that the Objectors have not established that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity or that the Will was procured through fraud, coercion or undue influence. The evidence also supports the finding that the Will is authentic and represents the deceased's testamentary wishes," the judge ruled.

The judge explained that succession law allows people to leave their property to beneficiaries of their choice.

Although Section 26 of the Law of Succession Act allows dependants who have not received reasonable provision to ask the court to make provision for them, the three children had not provided sufficient evidence of their financial needs, available resources, previous benefits from the deceased and the value of the estate.

"I have considered the evidence in the present case against those principles. The deceased expressly stated in clause 3 of the Will that she had made that disposition because all her sons and daughters had inherited her late husband's properties," the judge said, maintaining that the evidence presented was insufficient to determine whether they deserved additional provision from their mother's estate.

The ruling is important as it gives guidance that a parent can leave property to one child and exclude others, provided the Will is validly made.

Excluded children may, however, still seek reasonable provision under the Law of Succession Act.

An image of court files arranged in storage cabinets.

Photo

Law Web

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by Kenyans.co.ke
View on Kenyans.co.ke

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…