The High Court has lifted restrictions that had prevented Chief Justice Martha Koome and the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) from publishing individual performance records of judges and judicial officers in the State of the Judiciary and Administration of Justice Report (SOJAR).
In a ruling issued on Friday, Justice David Mburu set aside the conservatory orders he had issued the previous day, which barred the JSC and Chief Justice from publishing the individual performance records in the report, which was set to launch on Friday, November 20.
“The ex-parte conservatory order issued on 19.11.2026 (Order Number 3) prohibiting the 1st and 2nd respondents from publishing individual performance data for Judges and Judicial Officers as an addendum to, appendix to or in any other form, way or manner in the State of the Judiciary and the Administration of Justice Report (SOJAR), is hereby discharged,” stated official court documents obtained by this publication.
The judge explained that the restriction has been lifted after finding that circumstances had changed since the initial order was issued.
The Judiciary
Photo
JSC
“Upon considering the said application, the court is satisfied that the ex-parte conservatory order issued on 19.11.2026 has been overtaken by events. Courts do not issue orders in vain,” the judge added.
The initial directive followed a petition that challenged the planned disclosure of individual judicial performance figures, arguing that the move lacked a clear regulatory framework.
A petitioner raised concerns that publishing the figures without proper context could expose judicial officers to harassment and disclose sensitive personal information.
The application also questioned whether the information had been sufficiently verified, arguing that incomplete or selectively presented figures could create misleading impressions about the performance of individual judges.
The petitioner maintained that he was not opposed to accountability within the Judiciary but wanted clear guidelines established to ensure the information was presented fairly and accurately.
While the latest decision removes the legal barrier to publication, it does not amount to a final determination of the petition challenging the disclosure of the data.
Now, the court has certified the application as urgent and admitted it for an initial hearing without requiring the other parties to be heard first.
The matter is scheduled to return to court on December 1, 2026, when parties are expected to confirm the filing of their submissions and receive further directions.
A court Gavel.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.