By Luminous Jannamike
ABUJA – The Imo State Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice, Hon. Paul Obinatu, has challenged the authority of the National Judicial Council (NJC) to dictate the candidate the state’s Judicial Service Commission (JSC) should submit for consideration as substantive Chief Judge, describing the move as an encroachment on the Commission’s constitutional independence.
The disagreement centres on the extent of the NJC’s powers in the appointment process, with Obinatu insisting that its authority to recommend a candidate to the Governor does not extend to controlling the State Commission’s choice.
In a statement on Saturday, Obinatu was reacting to a directive reportedly issued by the NJC at its 112th meeting on November 3, concerning the appointment of a substantive Chief Judge for Imo State.
He said the NJC lacked the authority to interfere with the State Commission’s independent assessment and recommendation process under the 1999 Constitution, as amended.
Section 202 of the Constitution provides that a State Judicial Service Commission shall not be subject to the direction or control of any other authority or person in exercising its constitutional functions.
Obinatu argued that the provision prevents the NJC from dictating the candidate the Imo JSC must submit.
“Any directive requiring the State JSC to submit a particular candidate or dictating the outcome of its independent assessment would amount to unconstitutional interference,” he maintained.
He anchored his argument on Paragraph 6(a), Part II of the Third Schedule, which empowers the State JSC to advise the NJC on suitable candidates, and Paragraph 21(c), Part I, which empowers the NJC to recommend a candidate to the Governor from among the names submitted.
According to him, Section 271(1) further provides that the Governor appoints the Chief Judge on the NJC’s recommendation, subject to confirmation by the State House of Assembly.
“The NJC’s constitutional responsibility to recommend a candidate to the Governor does not confer on it the additional power to determine or dictate the candidate the State Judicial Service Commission must submit to it,” Obinatu said.
He also rejected the suggestion that the NJC’s Guidelines and Procedural Rules for the Appointment of Judicial Officers could justify the reported directive, insisting that administrative guidelines could not override constitutional provisions.
“Such guidelines cannot confer powers beyond those granted by the Constitution or be used to compromise the independent functions of the State JSC,” he said.
Obinatu cited several judicial decisions, including Elelu-Habeeb v. Attorney-General of the Federation (2012), Bamisile v. National Judicial Council (2012) and Attorney-General of the Federation v. Attorney-General of Abia State (2024), in support of his position that constitutional institutions must operate within their legally prescribed boundaries.
He insisted that the disagreement was not about institutional superiority but about protecting the respective constitutional responsibilities of both bodies.
“The issue is not a contest for institutional superiority between the NJC and the State JSC, but the need for each institution to respect the constitutional boundaries of its authority,” he said.
He warned that allowing the NJC to assume functions reserved for the State Commission would undermine the integrity of the Chief Judge appointment process and public confidence in the judiciary.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.