By Henry Ojelu
A Senior Advocate of Nigeria, Babatunde Fashanu, has asked a judge of the Federal High Court in Lagos, Justice Ambrose Lewis-Allagoa, to recuse himself from a suit over the leadership and governance of the Lagos Country Club, Ikeja.
The suit, was instituted by Fashanu against the Registered Trustees of the Lagos Country Club and some members of the club.
At the proceedings last Thursday, Fashanu, who appeared with J. Shaw, expressed dissatisfaction with the handling of the case, alleging that the club conducted elections into its management council despite pending court proceedings and three subsisting orders directing parties to maintain the status quo.
The SAN told the court that three applications filed on behalf of the plaintiff were yet to be determined. They include applications seeking to set aside the disputed elections, nullify the appointment of a caretaker committee and commence contempt proceedings against the respondents through Forms 48 and 49.
He urged the court to first address the alleged disobedience of its orders, arguing that parties should not be allowed to disregard judicial directives and subsequently benefit from such actions.
Citing the Supreme Court decision in Bureau of Public Enterprises v. BFI Group, Fashanu argued “that contempt proceedings arising from alleged disobedience of court orders should take precedence over other pending applications.”
However, counsel to the first defendant, D.J. Fadesere, urged the court to determine its jurisdiction before considering the contempt proceedings.
Fadesere said a preliminary objection challenging the court’s jurisdiction had been filed on May 29, 2025, arguing that the contempt issue could not arise if the court lacked jurisdiction over the substantive suit.
Another defence counsel, Ademola Adeshina, denied that the defendants acted in contempt of court, arguing that the disputed administrative actions were taken pursuant to a consent judgment delivered in another suit before the same court.
Adeshina further contended that Fashanu, not being a party to the other suit, lacked the legal standing to challenge the consent judgment.
In his ruling on the order of hearing, Justice Lewis-Allagoa held that jurisdiction was fundamental and should be determined first, particularly where the issue of contempt was linked to the court’s competence to entertain the substantive suit.
The judge said proceeding without jurisdiction would amount to a waste of judicial time.
Following the ruling, Fashanu raised concerns about possible bias, pointing out that Justice Lewis-Allagoa had earlier delivered a consent judgment in a related suit in which the club’s elections were upheld.
In response, Justice Lewis-Allagoa directed the SAN to file a formal application for recusal in accordance with the court’s rules to enable all parties to respond.
The matter was adjourned until January 12, 2027, for hearing of the formal application seeking the judge’s recusal.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.