Business / Nigeria

Nigeria can’t afford return of petrol subsidy – Author

Nigeria can’t afford return of petrol subsidy – Author

Nigerian author and development economist, Seun Awogbenle, has warned against calls for the restoration of petrol subsidy, arguing that returning to the policy would reverse the gains of ongoing economic reforms and worsen Nigeria’s fiscal challenges.

Awogbenle stated this in a speech delivered on Thursday at the National Policy Dialogue of the Institute of Legislative Studies, University of Ilorin.

In his lecture titled, “Interrogating the Political-Economic Substance of the Debate on Fuel Subsidy Removal versus Restoration: Which Should Interest Nigerians?”, he described the removal of petrol subsidy as necessary to address longstanding weaknesses in the country’s economic foundations, including mounting debts, low government revenue and the financial burden of multiple subsidies.

According to the economist, Nigeria had, before the removal of the subsidy in 2023, been borrowing to sustain artificially low petrol prices, while also pledging crude oil yet to be produced to creditors.

He said, “In May 2023, there were essentially three problems a fragile economy with mounting debts, low revenue, and multiple subsidies that created a big hole in our public finances.

“States were struggling to pay salaries, and fuel subsidies were taking up all our earnings.”

Awogbenle likened the country’s continued dependence on subsidy to borrowing from the future, referencing a story about a husband who exhausted his daily entitlement but asked his wife to lend him part of the following day’s allocation.

He argued that the subsidy arrangement had become unsustainable and that the 2023 reforms were necessary to prevent a further deterioration of the economy.

He noted that the removal of fuel subsidy, alongside foreign exchange liberalisation, banking sector recapitalisation and the clearing of foreign exchange backlogs, formed part of the major policy changes introduced by President Bola Tinubu’s administration.

However, he acknowledged that the reforms had brought unintended consequences, particularly higher food prices and transportation costs, which had placed pressure on households.

“The trouble, however, is that the reforms, while necessary, have created unintended consequences. Especially soaring food prices and a rise in the cost of transportation,” he said.

Awogbenle maintained that the debate should focus on how to address the effects of the reforms rather than restoring the subsidy.

He described calls for its return as dangerous, arguing that they could undermine the progress made under the current economic policies.

“But look, to bring back fuel subsidy is to take Nigerians back to the biblical Egypt. Even as mere political rhetoric, it is a dangerous proposition that sets Nigeria back by a mile,” he said.

He also questioned proposals for a producer-based subsidy, including the proposal attributed to former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar, which would provide discounted crude oil directly to local refiners.

According to him, Nigeria’s crude oil commitments to creditors could make it difficult to meet the demands of local refiners under such an arrangement.

He further asked how the difference between market prices and the proposed discounted prices would be funded, and whether state and local governments would agree to the financial implications.

Awogbenle said any renewed subsidy arrangement would also risk reversing gains from foreign exchange reforms, arguing that fuel subsidy and the exchange rate were closely connected.

He said, “Fuel subsidies follow the foreign exchange; to return fuel subsidies would be to also return the country to the days of pegging foreign exchange, and that would in effect undo all the gains we have made under current reforms.”

Instead, he urged the government to channel resources towards cushioning the effects of the reforms, particularly through interventions in food supply and mass transportation.

“I believe that if there was any debate at all, it must be on how to manage the attendant fallout and channel part of the fiscal headroom into sectors that provide some cushioning and direct relief to the most vulnerable,” he said.

He identified rising food and transportation costs as the two major pressures on household incomes and called for measures to make food more affordable, while encouraging state governments to introduce mass transit schemes.

Awogbenle also listed increased revenue to states, competitive exports, stronger foreign reserves, foreign exchange stability and an improved macroeconomic climate among the gains associated with the reforms.

He, however, described the rebuilding of Nigeria’s economic foundations as the most important benefit, saying it was necessary to attract investment, create jobs and support economic growth.

He argued that Nigeria needed to move from dependence on primary sectors such as farming, mining and extraction towards industrialisation, stressing that productivity required skills, capital and infrastructure.

“I am in no doubt that people must be at the centre of the government agenda, but there is almost nothing we can achieve as a nation when the assumptions and fundamentals that underpin our economy are contrived,” he said.

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by Punch
View on Punch

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…