Health / Nigeria

Nigeria’s insurers face claims, coverage test after recapitalisation

Nigeria’s insurers face claims, coverage test after recapitalisation

South Africa’s R5.2tn life insurance asset base offers valuable lessons for Nigeria as it considers strengthening its insurance industry through recapitalisation, writes Odinaka Anudu.

Nigeria’s insurance industry has raised N1.079tn through its latest recapitalisation exercise, but the real test of the reform will be whether the stronger capital base translates into faster claims payments, greater domestic risk retention and wider insurance coverage.

Despite its substantial financial resources and sophisticated solvency regulations, South Africa continues to grapple with rising policy lapses and a R50.4tn life and disability insurance gap, highlighting the limitations of capital strength without adequate consumer protection.

According to the Association for Savings and Investment South Africa, life insurers paid R626bn in claims and benefits in 2025.

They also held R380.5bn in capital available to cover their Solvency Capital Requirement of R222.9bn, representing a coverage ratio of 1.71 times the regulatory requirement.

However, the ratio declined from 1.99 times in 2024, showing that strong balance sheets do not eliminate financial and operational pressures.

Nigeria completed its 12-month recapitalisation exercise on 31 July, 2026, under the Nigerian Insurance Industry Reform Act 2025. NAICOM subsequently confirmed that 48 insurance companies and two reinsurers had met the new minimum capital requirements, while six insurers lost their licences.

The exercise mobilised N1.079tn in total industry capital, strengthening insurers’ capacity to underwrite larger risks and improve their financial resilience.

But South Africa’s experience suggests that recapitalisation should be the beginning of a broader regulatory and market reform rather than an end in itself.

Under its Solvency Assessment and Management framework, South Africa links insurers’ capital requirements to the risks they undertake. Its solvency requirements are designed to ensure that insurers can withstand a one-in-200-year risk event without compromising their obligations to policyholders.

Nigeria is also moving towards risk-based supervision. In June 2026, NAICOM appointed Ernst & Young as consulting actuary to support the finalisation and implementation of its Risk-Based Capital framework. The initiative is expected to move supervision beyond fixed minimum capital thresholds towards assessing the financial resources individual insurers need to support their actual risk exposures.

Claims settlement test

Nigeria’s insurance market recorded gross premiums of N2.3tn in the fourth quarter of 2025, while gross claims reached N724.7bn, according to figures from NAICOM’s market performance report.

The reported claims settlement ratios were 65.5 per cent for life insurance and 75.5 per cent for non-life insurance. These figures highlight the importance of improving claims administration and customer experience as insurers emerge from recapitalisation.

South Africa provides another useful comparison. Its life insurers paid R626bn in total claims and benefits in 2025, covering death, disability, critical illness, retirement and other policy obligations.

Yet, financial strength has not eliminated the problem of inadequate insurance coverage.

ASISA’s 2025 Insurance Gap Study found that South Africa’s life and disability insurance gap widened to R50.4tn at December 2024. The country’s 16.1 million formally employed income earners had sufficient cover to replace only 39 per cent of the income their families would need following death or permanent disability.

Policy lapses also increased to 8.7 million in 2025 from 8.2 million in 2024, reflecting the difficulty some households face in maintaining insurance protection.

Turning capital value

For Nigeria, the challenge is to ensure that additional capital translates into greater domestic underwriting capacity, particularly in oil and gas, aviation, marine, construction and infrastructure.

The country’s overall market retention ratio stood at 68.1 per cent in Q4 of 2025, but retention was considerably weaker in some major risk classes. Oil and gas recorded 43 per cent, aviation 30 per cent and marine 47 per cent.

These figures show why stronger capital matters, as insurers need sufficient financial resources to retain more risks instead of transferring substantial portions of premiums abroad.

However, capital mobilisation alone will not expand the market. Insurers must develop affordable products for households, small businesses, farmers and informal-sector operators who remain underserved.

Minister of Finance, Taiwo Oyedele, said in Lagos on Thursday that there was a need for affordable and accessible insurance products for households, small businesses, farmers and underserved communities, stressing that insurance should become an everyday financial protection mechanism rather than a privilege for a limited segment of the population.

Ultimately, Nigeria’s N1.079tn recapitalisation should be judged not simply by the number of companies that met the new requirements, but by improvements in claims payments, risk retention, product affordability and insurance penetration.

South Africa demonstrates that even a well-capitalised industry can have substantial protection gaps. Nigeria must therefore ensure that stronger balance sheets translate into meaningful financial security for policyholders.

The Commissioner for Insurance and Chief Executive of NAICOM, Olusegun Omosehin, warned last week that capital could be depleted through poor underwriting decisions, excessive operating expenses, inappropriate investments and uncontrolled business expansion.

Omosehin said the success of recapitalisation would ultimately depend on whether insurers could convert stronger capital positions into improved claims settlement, sustainable growth and greater public confidence.

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by Punch
View on Punch

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…