Politics / Nigeria

NIMR in Turmoil: ASURI lawyer explains legal battle dividing Nigeria’s top Research Institute

NIMR in Turmoil: ASURI lawyer explains legal battle dividing Nigeria’s top Research Institute

By Ishola Balogun

The Nigeria Institute of Medical Research (NIMR), Nigeria’s premier medical research institution, is facing one of the most turbulent periods in its history. What began as a dispute over the application of the Federal Government’s eight-year director tenure policy has snowballed into a wider crisis involving court actions, allegations of staff intimidation, eviction threats, salary stoppages, and concerns over the disruption of critical research activities. At the heart of the controversy is a bitter standoff between the institute’s management, led by Director-General Professor John Obafunwa, and three directors and research fellows who insist that their appointments and conditions of service are protected by existing regulations governing research institutions.

In this interview with Saturday Vanguard, Legal Counsel to the Academic Staff Union of Research Institutions (ASURI), Anthony Itedjere, speaks on the legal battle over the tenure policy, the ongoing court proceedings, allegations that NIMR management is failing to maintain the status quo pending judicial determination, and why the union believes the conflict has implications beyond NIMR and for the future of research administration in Nigeria.

Could you give your perspective to clarify the exact court order or process regarding the eight-year tenure policy for directors in research institutes as it affects the Nigeria Institute of Medical Research (NIMR), and what actions ASSURI believes constitute a breach of the court process?

Let me provide the correct perspective on the facts of the case as they stand today.

ASSURI, the Office of the Head of Service, and several other ministries and parastatals have common conditions of service for all government research and development workers.

Under those terms and conditions of service, the retirement age is 65 years. That is what is stipulated in their conditions of service.

Sometime during the Obasanjo administration, however, the Federal Government introduced the eight-year director tenure policy. In essence, once a director has served in that position for eight years, he or she is required to retire.

Over the years, the Office of the Head of Service issued several clarifications excluding research and development staff from this policy, maintaining that the eight-year tenure rule does not apply to directors and research staff who are on the academic career track.

In fact, one of the circulars specifically stated that the office of a director within research institutes should be administered in the same manner as that of a Head of Department in other academic institutions.

For instance, in a university, a professor may also serve as a Head of Department. After completing the tenure as HOD, the professor returns to regular academic duties. That was the arrangement under which these research staff operated.

Suddenly and unexpectedly, sometime early this year, the Office of the Head of Service issued a circular drawing the attention of several government parastatals and ministries to the effect that some institutions appeared not to be complying with the eight-year director tenure policy.

Ordinarily, that circular was intended for institutions subject to the policy. Unfortunately, some institutions, including the Nigeria Institute of Medical Research, interpreted it as an instruction requiring their directors to retire. However, the circular never said so. It merely stated that an earlier Federal Government circular appeared not to have been implemented. When that earlier circular was issued, the Office of the Head of Service had already clarified that research institutes were excluded from the policy.

The January circular did not state that the exclusion had been withdrawn. Neither did it override the previous circular that clarified the eight-year policy and exempted research institutes.

When this occurred, ASSURI considered it a trade dispute and formally declared one.

Under Nigeria’s labour jurisprudence, once a trade dispute is declared, it must pass through the processes of conciliation, mediation, and arbitration before it can proceed to the National Industrial Court.

ASSURI declared the trade dispute, and mediation and conciliation commenced. Unfortunately, those processes had not been concluded when NIMR threatened to evict the affected professors from their official quarters.

There is a legal process governing trade disputes, including conciliation and mediation, as provided for under Section 7 of the National Industrial Court Act and reaffirmed by Section 254C of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended in third Alteration).

What ASSURI is saying is that these individuals cannot be ejected while the process of determining whether their employment can lawfully be terminated in the manner adopted by the institute is still ongoing.

Because this is a quasi-judicial process, we approached the National Industrial Court and filed an application.

That application was filed on August 26, 2026. We also wrote to the institute, informing it that while the suit is on, as well as the mediation and conciliation processes, remained ongoing, it could not proceed with evicting these professors. It appeared that the institute was attempting to resort to self-help.

In the well-known case of Military Governor of Lagos State v. Ojukwu, the Supreme Court held that even government institutions cannot resort to self-help.

The parties had already submitted themselves to the legal process. We filed the suit and placed the matter before the court, asking it to determine the proper legal position regarding the termination of these appointments.

The question before the court is whether the institute can terminate the employment of these staff members under the eight-year director tenure policy without violating their conditions of service.

The application came up on October 19, 2026. Unfortunately, the court was unable to sit on that date, and the matter was subsequently adjourned to December 7.

While these issues remain before the court, they are generally regarded as sub judice.

The question of whether the institute can evict staff during the pendency of the mediation and conciliation process is already before the National Industrial Court.

We have challenged the letters threatening to eject them from their respective official residences.

Our position is that once legal processes have been served, a party cannot take steps that would overreach or undermine the proceedings before the court.

The authorities are clear on this. Once you become aware that a party has approached the court seeking an order against you, you are expected to refrain from taking actions that could overreach the proceedings. Such conduct may amount to contempt. It is commonly referred to as contempt in relation to pending judicial proceedings.

When a matter is before a court and a party takes steps that undermine those proceedings or render the court ineffective, the court is entitled to call that party to order.

We do not wish to pursue that route with the institute. That is why, when the letters were issued, we also wrote to the institute, urging it not to take actions that could be perceived as interfering with the judicial process.

Whatever actions are being taken to evict these individuals amount to an affront to the court and are judicially unacceptable.

What about the case involving Rekiya Eliyasu, who approached the National Industrial Court seeking a definitive interpretation of the matter, which was decided by Justice Olufunke Anuwe?

The court has been consistent on this issue.

In labour jurisprudence, conditions of service are extremely important, particularly in light of the Harmonised Teachers’ Retirement Age Act.

It is surprising that, under that Act, primary school teachers can remain in service until the age of 65, yet professors engaged in research and development are being asked to retire before reaching that age.

Do we really need the court to interpret this for us? If you read the Teachers’ Retirement Act, it is quite clear. Those who qualify as teachers under the interpretation clause of the Act are entitled to retire at the age of 65.

Based on both the conditions of service and the provisions of the Teachers’ Retirement Act, the courts have consistently held in several decisions that employers cannot misinterpret the law in order to compel such employees to retire before attaining the age of 65.

If an employee chooses to retire voluntarily, that is entirely acceptable. However, under the current state of the law, neither the Federal Government nor a state government employer can lawfully terminate the appointment of such employees before they attain the mandatory retirement age of 65 years.

That was the position adopted by the court, and we believe the court will agree with us that these employees cannot be compelled to leave the system before attaining the age of 65.

Despite this, threats of eviction, salary stoppages, and removal from office are still being issued. What are the implications or consequences of failing to maintain the status quo and showing disregard for the judicial process?

The judicial process has restorative powers. The courts can restore parties to the position they occupied before the disputed actions occurred. That is often the type of relief granted in such situations.

In some courts, including the FCT High Court, once a suit is filed, there is a notice on the first page directing parties to refrain from taking further steps regarding the subject matter of the suit.

In practical terms, it operates almost like an immediate directive to maintain the status quo. That reflects the current approach of our legal system.

Once a suit has been filed and the parties have been served, they are expected, even in the absence of a specific court order, not to take actions that would overreach the proceedings before the court.

This does not mean that a party cannot retrace its steps. If a party realises an error has been made and wishes to resolve the matter amicably, the court welcomes that.

However, a party cannot continue taking steps relating to the subject matter already before the court in a manner that undermines the pending proceedings.

For example, if I file a suit and you later realise that you were mistaken and decide to settle the matter, the court has no objection to that.

However, insisting on proceeding with actions that are already the subject of litigation constitutes an affront to the court.

At that point, the issue is no longer merely between the parties. It becomes an issue between that party and the court. In effect, such conduct amounts to a confrontation with the judiciary itself. The party is no longer disrespecting merely the opposing party but the institution of the judiciary.

That is why every court and every judge treats the issue of contempt very seriously.

Indeed, in certain circumstances, contempt proceedings may take precedence over questions of jurisdiction. When a party is in contempt, that issue may need to be resolved before the court proceeds to consider whether it has jurisdiction.

I have written to NIMR on at least two occasions, and we ensured that those letters were hand-delivered to the institute, informing it that the matter is before the court.

We also provided an advance copy of the court processes, and we understand that the court has likewise served the institute. We served it ourselves as well. Therefore, it cannot claim ignorance.

The institute is fully aware that these proceedings, and the actions it is seeking to take, have been the subject of litigation since August 26, 2026.

It knows that any proposed action, particularly the eviction of these employees, is already a matter before the National Industrial Court.

The only additional point I wish to make, which I have stated repeatedly, is that the court must be allowed to perform its statutory functions.

Parties are expected to cease hostilities once a matter has been submitted to the court for adjudication.

Any step taken to overreach the proceedings is no longer merely an action against the opposing party. It is an affront to the court and may be regarded as contempt of court.

If a party is waiting for a formal court order before taking steps to preserve the status quo, it is treading a very dangerous path. That position is not legally sustainable, and the court may take a very dim view of such conduct, as though an order had already been granted.

My advice to the institute is to suspend further action, cease all threats and hostile measures, and allow the judicial process to run its full course.

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by Vanguard
View on Vanguard

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…