By Douglas Baye-Osagie
The Nigerian Senate was discussed on Wednesday November 4th, 2026 in the manner it should be talked about which is Lawmaking. For once, the national conversation was not about defections or drama on the floor. It was about a law that could decide whether a Nigerian lives or dies in the next fifteen minutes.
The Bill, which is an amendment to the National Health Act, sponsored by Sen Abdulaziz Musa Yar’adua representing Katsina Central Senatorial District elicited a nationwide conversation. It seeks to compel hospitals to “attend” to emergency cases within fifteen minutes of arrival, without demanding payment first. It is simple, it is direct, and it is long overdue.
The reaction from some doctors was swift and emotional. Many argued that emergency care already exists, that they are already trained, and that no doctor would ever turn away a true emergency. That passion is understandable, because doctors carry the heaviest burden of our broken system every day.
What many do not realise is that the National Health Act already mandates emergency care and treatment. Section 20, which deals with emergency treatment, states that:
- A health care provider, health worker or health establishment shall not refuse a person emergency medical treatment for any reason.
- A person who contravenes this section commits an offence and is liable on conviction to a fine of ₦100,000 or to imprisonment for a period not exceeding six months or to both.
So a lawyer already has the arsenal to sue the health facility in Nigeria for turning down a patient. This is not a Yar’adua invention. It is already Law in Nigeria.
What the Senator is doing is not inventing a new duty. He is trying to structure the timeline like it is done in most countries in the world. The current subsection does not clearly specify procedures and timelines required. It says do not refuse, but it does not say how fast to triage, how fast to stabilize, who pays, and how the hospital is reimbursed. Without a timeline, the law is a good intention without enforcement. With a timeline it becomes a measurable standard. This is what might trigger more private funds and the likelihood of more enrollment on the NHIS scheme, because investors and insurers can finally plan around a defined service.
While we appreciate their candidness and fervour in Doctors and other health workers sharing their side of the discussion, we must say respectfully that they are wrong on a number of points. Good intentions are not a system. Individual sacrifice is not a policy. And a country of over 230 million people cannot run its emergency care on the goodwill of tired doctors alone.
They claim that no doctor will see a true emergency and look the other way. While this may be true for some, it is largely inaccurate to say no doctor. If it is true, why do we repeatedly hear the plethora of stories of people being turned away from hospitals due to lack of ability to pay?
We all remember the pregnant woman in Lagos whose story trended after she was allegedly denied timely care. We remember the influencer who was locked outside the gate at LASUTH. We remember countless unnamed Nigerians who died at hospital gates, not because there was no bed or no equipment, but because there was no deposit.
Those incidents had nothing to do with lack of equipment or bed space. They had to do with a system that allowed human beings to be treated as transactions first and patients second. They had to do with the sheer lack of empathy and the human side of care. A law is needed precisely because good character cannot be assumed in every facility, every shift, and every state.
The second claim is about training to attend to emergencies. It would seem it is some of our critics who are not well informed about what modern emergency care actually requires. Attending to emergencies is not the same as having a fully developed emergency medicine system.
Are you aware that in the societies which most of our doctors want to japa to, there is a Residency program in Emergency Medicine, just like you have residency in Surgery, Paediatrics or Obstetrics? Are you aware that doctors spend four to five years in a residency program just learning about Emergency Medicine?
Those societies have this exact same stipulated timeframe for emergency room response because they understand that time is tissue, time is blood, and time is life. Even our neighbour Ghana has a 30 minute timeframe to triage and stabilize. Even small Sierra Leone does. These are countries we have more healthcare workforce than, yet they have defined what their citizens should expect.
Nigeria cannot continue to argue that we are different. A heart attack does not wait for our excuses. A road traffic accident does not wait for our infrastructure debate. A woman bleeding after childbirth does not wait for us to fix the whole country first. She needs a standard, and she needs it now.
Access to timely emergency medical care is a cornerstone of any functional health system. Yet in Nigeria, preventable deaths persist because there are no clearly defined and enforceable timelines for triage, the process of quickly assessing and prioritizing patients based on the severity of their condition to determine the order of treatment. Delays in these first critical minutes often determine survival. When there is no law that says how fast a patient must be seen, delay becomes normal, and normal delay becomes death.
The numbers tell the story more powerfully than any argument. Nigeria alone accounts for approximately 10 percent of global maternal deaths, with delayed access to emergency obstetric care as a leading factor. These are not women who could not be saved, they are women who were not reached in time. The most recent published statistics on road accidents by the Federal Road Safety Commission show that from 7,715 crashes between January and September 2025, there were 3,915 deaths and 24,617 injuries.
Behind each of those numbers is a family that waited at a hospital gate, waited for a deposit, waited for a referral, or waited for someone to decide that their case was urgent enough. This is why this Bill deserves engagement and support, not dismissal. It is not about blaming doctors, it is about ending a system where survival depends on luck and money, instead of time and law.
While we would not dismiss the need for upgrades of our infrastructure, this Bill is the most effective way to define what exactly our yardstick, goal, metric, and KPI should be as it regards emergency care. Then we can build around it. Investors can then invest in that space.
That is how serious sectors are built. You do not wait for perfection before you set a standard. You set the standard, and the standard forces investment, training, equipment, and accountability to follow. Without a standard, everyone can claim they are doing their best while patients keep dying.
The healthcare space has been starved of capital and investment because of the lack of regulation and clearly defined rules. No serious investor will put billions into a sector where there is no defined service level, no accountability, and no enforceable patient right. Capital follows clarity.
The same rules that exist in the banking sector and petroleum sector have led to the vast boom in capital, investments, and the growth of those sectors. Banking did not grow because bankers were simply nicer people. It grew because of strong legislation, the Central Bank Act, the NDIC Act, BVN, KYC, and clear penalties for failure.
Telecommunications is another example. Before the Nigerian Communications Act of 2003 and the creation of a strong regulator, telephone lines were a luxury for the rich. Once the law created a clear framework, competition, licensing, and consumer protection, investment poured in. Today, even a farmer in a remote village has a phone. That transformation came from legislation, not from pleas for handouts.
The pension sector tells the same story. Before the Pension Reform Act of 2004, retirees died waiting for their gratuity. After the law created contributory pensions, PenCom, and clear custodianship rules, trillions of naira are now under management and pensioners have a system they can track. Law created trust, and trust created capital.
The petroleum sector, after decades of opacity, was transformed by the Petroleum Industry Act. Investors may still complain, but for the first time there is a single, defined legal framework for upstream, midstream, and downstream operations. Healthcare needs its own version of that clarity, and this amendment to the National Health Act is a crucial part of it.
The average Nigerian doctor thinks the problem with the health sector is government and lack of equipment. Government failure is real, and lack of equipment is real, but that diagnosis is incomplete. Government alone cannot fund a health system for 230 million people, and waiting for the government to buy every machine is why we are stuck. The health sector needs more private injection of funds, and that can only happen when there are legislations that strengthen private involvement. Private capital needs a guarantee that if it builds an emergency centre, buys ambulances, or trains paramedics, it will be paid, protected, and regulated fairly. This Bill provides that guarantee. It turns emergency care from a charity case into a viable service that private investors, insurers, and even doctors themselves can build businesses and careers around.
The NHS is often cited by Nigerian doctors as a model, but the NHS is not running efficiently because of government alone. It is the whole of the UK funding the health sector through taxation and National Insurance. Every worker contributes, every employer contributes, and every citizen knows they have a right to care.
In the UK, a patient does not need to negotiate payment while bleeding. The system was designed around the citizen, not around the facility. The law guarantees access, and the funding follows the law. Nigeria must learn that lesson. We cannot have a NHS standard of expectation with a no-standard legal framework.
Even in the UK, the ambulance system is not 100 percent government, as private sector involvement helps the NHS ambulance by filling gaps the NHS cannot cover, with private firms handling 999 overflow during surges, non-emergency patient transport for dialysis and routine appointments, inter-hospital transfers, and event medical cover, and they make their money not by charging a bleeding patient at the roadside but from NHS block contracts and per-journey payments, contracts with care homes, hospitals and insurers, direct private bookings, and event fees, all under the same CQC regulation as NHS ambulances.
The old law was a moral statement, but the new Bill is a business plan. The old law simply said do not refuse emergency treatment. The new Bill breaks that duty into measurable timelines: triage and initial assessment within 15 minutes, basic stabilization with oxygen, IV fluids, pain relief and initial diagnostics within 30 minutes, life-saving interventions like CPR, airway management and bleeding control immediately upon recognition of a life-threatening condition, bed assignment within 2 hours where bed space is available, commencement of referral within 2 hours and completion of transfer within 3 hours where bed space is unavailable, and ambulance dispatch or secure transportation within 30 minutes of the decision to refer.
Each of those timelines creates a bankable market that did not exist before. The 15-minute triage rule creates demand for triage bays, triage software and trained nurses. The 30-minute stabilization rule creates demand for oxygen plants, IV fluids, monitors and point-of-care diagnostics. The 2-hour and 3-hour referral and transfer rules create demand for private ambulance fleets, dispatch centres and digital referral platforms, because hospitals will now need to buy a guaranteed response to stay legal. The requirement that all emergency workers be trained and re-certified at intervals not exceeding 18 months, under a standardized national curriculum from the Medical and Dental Council and the Nursing and Midwifery Council, creates a recurring market for simulation centres, CPR training companies and e-learning providers.
Crucially, the new Bill also increases the penalty to a fine not exceeding ₦300,000 or six months imprisonment, but it adds the protection the old law never had: a healthcare practitioner who documents their inability to comply due to lack of resources shall not be penalized, provided they have followed the referral protocol and reported the incident to hospital management or the relevant authority. That protection is what makes the system investable. It reassures doctors that they will not be punished for institutional failure, it allows insurers to price risk around compliance, and it allows investors to put money into oxygen, ambulances, training and beds knowing that hospitals must buy those services to comply with the law. That is how a standard attracts capital.
Despite ignorance and lack of belief in our health system, a functional ambulance system might be the trigger for millions of Nigerians in the informal sector to enroll in the NHIS scheme which guarantees affordable medical care. That will naturally pump billions into the health sector without waiting for budgetary allocation.
The NHIA numbers should worry doctors more than the Bill. Let us face the numbers. According to the NHIA Director-General, Dr Kelechi Ohiri, health insurance enrolment in Nigeria rose to 23.06 million people in the second quarter of 2026, up from 16.2 million in late 2023 — a growth of 42.35 per cent. That is progress, but it is still only about 1 in 10 Nigerians in a country of over 230 million. The Federal Government target is 44 million by 2030, yet out-of-pocket spending still accounts for about 71 per cent of total health expenditure.
Under the National Health Insurance Act 2022, health insurance is now mandatory for all Nigerians. The old NHIS became the National Health Insurance Authority (NHIA). Employers with five or more staff must enrol their employees. Self-employed Nigerians, traders, artisans and those outside formal employment register under GIFSHIP — the Group, Individual and Family Social Health Insurance Programme. The NHIA ID card costs ₦1,500 and you need your NIN to register.
So why have Nigerians not embraced it? Doctors should be worried about this, not just about the Bill. Many Nigerians are either ignorant of the benefits or completely unaware that they can be enrolled. Many do not trust that if they pay, the hospital will actually treat them when they are sick. Many have watched a neighbour with a card still be asked to pay cash, still be told a drug is not covered, still be made to wait. Many in the informal sector — who are the majority of Nigeria — have never been told in a language and place they understand how GIFSHIP works. And many simply do not see the value, because there is no visible, guaranteed emergency service that proves insurance works when it matters most.
That is exactly why this 15 Minutes Bill matters. A functional, guaranteed emergency system is the most powerful advert for NHIA. If a trader knows that an ambulance will come, that he will be attended to within 15 minutes, and that his NHIA card will cover it, he will enrol. If a mother knows her child will not die at the gate for lack of deposit, she will enrol. Trust is not built by sensitisation workshops alone. Trust is built when the system works in the worst 15 minutes of a person’s life.
The Bill protects doctors too. It defines what stabilization means. It defines when referral is appropriate. It creates a legal basis for the government to reimburse hospitals for emergency care, so that hospitals are not forced to absorb the cost alone. Without this law, doctors will continue to be blamed for systemic failures they did not create.
To say doctors are given a blunt knife to fall an Iroko tree and then sanctioned is to miss the point. This Bill is not giving the blunt knife. It is demanding that we finally sharpen the knife, provide the tools, and stop pretending that the blunt knife is acceptable. A standard forces the government to provide the tools.
I have read the statement of the Nigerian Association of Resident Doctors dated November 5, 2026, rejecting the Bill because it proposes a six-month jail term or a fine of up to ₦300,000 for delays in emergency treatment and referral. We understand their frustration, and their statement that you cannot legislate oxygen into an empty cylinder, electricity into a dark operating theatre, or life-saving equipment into an inadequately funded hospital, is a powerful description of what doctors face daily. But we must respond honestly: the punishment they are rejecting already exists in the National Health Act. Section 20 already provides for a fine of ₦100,000 or six months imprisonment for refusing emergency treatment. The Bill is not inventing criminalisation, it is trying to make an unenforceable law enforceable by adding what was missing, a timeline, a procedure, and a funding and reimbursement mechanism. NARD is right that safeguards must be explicit, comprehensive and enforceable so that no doctor is punished for institutional failure, unavailable equipment, inadequate staffing, or circumstances beyond their control, and that safeguard should be written into the Bill during public hearing, not used as a reason to kill the Bill.
NARD says the National Assembly is criminalising the victims of a broken system instead of funding it, and that more penalties will accelerate japa. That fear is valid, but withdrawal is not a strategy. The doctors should sit down and bring a smarter argument. Nigeria belongs to everyone and every sector must put in their thinking cap. If the telecommunication sector had waited for NITEL, we might still be queuing up in our friends’ houses waiting for calls. If the petroleum sector had waited for NNPC alone, we might be buying fuel at ₦4,000 per litre now. If we did not recapitalise our banking sector, we should be seeing our banks close down and run away with our money. In each case, it was not more government handouts that saved the sector, it was policy, law, and private capital that forced the sector to grow. Waiting for the government to be the driver of our healthcare system must begin with policies, not just funds. Funds without policy disappear. Policy creates the system that attracts funds.
Japa did not start with this government, and it did not start with a previous PDP government either. In the 1990s, Saudi Arabia and the Arab world were the go-to destination for fresh and young doctors looking to make money. Today, the UK and Canada are the in-thing. The destination changes, the reason does not: doctors go where the system pays, protects and rewards them. If we do not create legislation that brings private funds into our health sector, our doctors will soon be searching for opportunities in Ghana and Burkina Faso in no distant time. That is why this Bill matters. It is not about punishment, it is about building a system worth staying for.
Healthcare does not want to face accountability, structure, or regulation, but keeps wanting to receive handouts and keep complaining when the handouts are not given. That model has failed. We cannot keep funding a system that has no measurable promise to the patient.
The Bill is not foolish. And the Senator and the team that put it together are brilliant people who have seen the problem and want to tackle it from the root rather than patch it. They understand that Nigeria does not have an emergency care problem because doctors are wicked. It has one because Nigeria has never legally defined emergency care as a right.
If this Bill passes and is enforced, hospitals will be forced to create triage units. State governments will be forced to fund ambulance services and paramedics. The private sector will see a bankable opportunity in emergency centres, air ambulances, and insurance for emergency care. That is how a sector is built.
In the end, this is not a fight between the Senate and doctors. It is a fight for the Nigerian who may be the next victim of a road accident, a collapsed building, or a sudden complication in pregnancy. That Nigerian deserves more than sympathy. That Nigerian deserves fifteen minutes of guaranteed action, backed by law.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.