Politics / Nigeria

Senate demands justice for 37 miners who died in NSCDC custody

Senate demands justice for 37 miners who died in NSCDC custody

The Senate has called on the Federal Government to ensure justice for 37 young artisanal miners who died in the custody of the Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps (NSCDC) in Minna, Niger State, demanding full implementation of the recommendations of the Federal Government’s investigative committee.

It also resolved to constitute a delegation, to be led by the President of the Senate, Godswill Akpabio, or his nominee, to visit the families of the deceased and convey the National Assembly’s condolences and solidarity.

The resolutions followed the adoption of a motion sponsored by Sani Musa and co-sponsored by other senators from the North Central region during Wednesday’s plenary.

The 37 young men died on September 17, while in the custody of the Niger State Command of the NSCDC, following their arrest during an operation against suspected illegal mining activities.

Presenting the motion, Musa said the incident raised serious questions about detention conditions, the protection of fundamental human rights and the obligation of security agencies to preserve the lives of persons in their custody.

He described the deaths as a painful tragedy that had devastated the families, relatives and communities of the victims.

The Senate noted that the Federal Government had constituted a 10-member independent investigative committee to determine the circumstances surrounding the incident, establish responsibility and recommend appropriate disciplinary and administrative actions.

It further observed that the committee had submitted its findings, identifying serious lapses and recommending sanctions, institutional reforms and financial compensation for the families of the deceased and other affected persons.

Musa said prompt implementation of the recommendations would demonstrate the government’s commitment to protecting the lives and fundamental rights of Nigerians.

He warned that failure to act, particularly on the payment of compensation to the bereaved families, could worsen their suffering and weaken public confidence in the government’s commitment to accountability and justice.

The Senate consequently urged the Federal Government to implement the committee’s recommendations, with particular attention to holding culpable officers accountable, imposing appropriate sanctions and undertaking institutional reforms within the NSCDC.

Contributing to the debate, Ned Nwoko, representing Delta North, described the incident as a national tragedy, insisting that the protection of human life must remain paramount, regardless of the circumstances surrounding an individual’s arrest.

He argued that allegations of involvement in illegal activities should not diminish the value attached to the lives of those who died.

He said, “However, the fact that some of these young men may have been involved in illegal activities should not mean that their lives are not valued.”

Nwoko drew comparisons with incidents in oil-producing communities in the South-South, where young people suspected of involvement in illegal activities had reportedly died during security operations.

He called for uniform standards of accountability in addressing such incidents across the country.

“Life is life, regardless of the circumstances. We should be consistent in how we respond to such incidents,” he said.

Akpabio commended Musa for bringing the matter before the Senate, noting that the incident had generated widespread public concern and attracted considerable attention in both traditional and social media.

He also acknowledged President Bola Tinubu’s intervention in setting up the investigative committee, stressing that its findings and recommendations must be acted upon.

The Senate President subsequently subjected the prayers of the motion to a voice vote, and they were adopted.

To ensure compliance, the chamber directed relevant committees, including those on Solid Minerals, Interior, Human Rights, Police Affairs and Judiciary, to monitor the implementation of the recommendations and report their findings to the Senate.

However, the proceedings took a different turn when Adams Oshiomhole proposed an additional resolution condemning illegal mining and calling on traditional rulers, state governments and local government authorities to intensify public sensitisation against the practice.

Oshiomhole argued that while the Senate was seeking justice over the deaths, it was necessary to make its position on illegal mining equally clear.

He said, “Illegal mining is a crime. It is an attempt to divert the country’s resources into private pockets, and anyone involved must face the consequences of the law.”

The former Edo State governor cautioned against interpreting the Senate’s position as an endorsement of illegal mining or a celebration of individuals suspected of criminal activities.

Solomon Lalong, representing Plateau South, seconded the additional prayer.

In response, Akpabio clarified that the Senate’s concern was rooted in the legal principle that every person was presumed innocent until proven guilty by a court.

He maintained that the arrest of the deceased on suspicion of illegal mining did not amount to a conviction.

“The Nigerian law presumes every person innocent until proven guilty. That is the most important point here,” Akpabio said.

He explained that the Senate’s decision to express sympathy for the deceased was informed by the fact that none of them had been convicted, adding that they were entitled to defend themselves through the judicial process.

“If they had been prosecuted, they would have had the opportunity to defend themselves. Unfortunately, they died under circumstances that are tragic and questionable,” he said.

Akpabio also defended the Senate’s decision to observe a minute of silence in honour of the deceased, saying the chamber was concerned about the circumstances of their deaths and the need to secure justice for their families.

The additional prayer condemning illegal mining and urging traditional rulers, governors and local government authorities to sensitise their communities was subsequently adopted.

However, Mohammed Ali Ndume raised a point of order, questioning the relevance of the additional resolution to the substantive motion.

Citing Order 56 of the Senate Rules, Ndume argued that the motion before the chamber was specifically concerned with the deaths of the 37 miners in NSCDC custody and the implementation of the investigative committee’s recommendations.

He maintained that the issue at hand was the protection of human life and the circumstances surrounding the deaths, rather than illegal mining.

Akpabio, however, maintained that the additional prayer had already been adopted, while reiterating that the central concern of the motion remained justice for the deceased and their families.

The Senate’s intervention comes amid increasing demands for accountability and improved standards in the country’s security and detention facilities following the Minna incident.

The Federal Government had constituted the independent investigative committee on the directive of President Tinubu, who ordered a comprehensive investigation into the deaths.

The committee’s report, submitted in October, attributed the deaths to severe overcrowding, inadequate ventilation, heat stress and dehydration, describing the tragedy as preventable.

It also recommended compensation for the affected families and survivors, disciplinary measures against officers found culpable and comprehensive institutional reforms.

The Senate’s resolutions are expected to intensify legislative pressure on the Federal Government and the NSCDC to act on the findings, ensure accountability and introduce safeguards against a recurrence of the tragedy.

Add BusinessDay as a preferred source on Google Follow BusinessDay on Google News

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by BusinessDay
View on BusinessDay

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…