Politics / Nigeria

The economics of silence and the front-page primary

(This is the second and concluding instalment of a two-part column. The first, “The press: Guardian or gladiator?,” was published last week.)

Politicians understand the value of appearing on newspaper front pages, and they fight for it at any cost. Newspapers run what I call the ‘Front Page Primary’ long before voters reach the polls. While they do not determine election results, and prominence does not automatically translate into votes, their choices shape what citizens see, discuss, and consider worthy of scrutiny.

Silence is the other side of this contest. It does not necessarily mean deliberately suppressing a story. It may take the form of recurring omissions: the smaller party that rarely makes the news, the rural community whose concerns receive scant attention, or the citizens whose experiences politicians invoke but journalists seldom hear directly.

Such absences may arise from editorial judgement, limited resources, or commercial pressure. Their cumulative effect, however, is to present a narrower picture of the country than the electorate deserves.

The economic dimension of this silence is particularly troubling: what receives little attention may eventually be mistaken for what does not matter. Professor Ishmael Ibrahim of the University of Lagos described a related tendency as ‘Casino Journalism.’

The phrase is striking, but its significance lies in the question it raises about a profession whose public responsibilities must coexist with the commercial demands of keeping a newsroom alive.

Eze Anaba, President of the Nigerian Guild of Editors, put the commercial dimension bluntly: “Don’t forget election campaign season is a season for money-making in the media.” The remark is not, in itself, evidence of editorial compromise.

It is an invitation to examine the conditions under which political reporting is produced, and the point at which the legitimate need to earn revenue begins to threaten the public duty to scrutinise those who provide it.

Wrap around ads? Very legitimate. But the concern becomes sharper when political advertising and editorial prominence occupy the same space. My analysis of the 2023 elections raises an uncomfortable question about paid front-page wraps: in the editions examined, I found no negative lead story about a candidate who had paid for a wrap in that same edition.

That pattern does not, by itself, prove that payment purchased favourable coverage. It does, however, warrant transparent examination. Readers should never have to guess whether the page is reporting political power or selling it.

Advertising must be unmistakably identified, and the commercial department must not possess an informal veto over editorial judgement. This is the ‘Advertiser’s Veto’ in its most troubling form: not necessarily a written instruction, but the possibility that revenue quietly narrows what can be published.

Dapo Olorunyomi’s concerns about fragile newsrooms and the logistical assistance that political parties sometimes provide journalists point to a structural difficulty. Reporting costs money: transport, accommodation, data, research time, and the patient verification that serious investigation demands.

When a newsroom cannot meet those costs, assistance from the people being covered may create an obligation, or at least the appearance of one.

An investigation may be postponed, a reporter may rely on a party’s transport, a local assignment may be abandoned, or a press release may be published because it is quicker and cheaper than independent reporting.

None of these circumstances automatically proves improper influence. Together, however, they show why financial sustainability cannot be separated from editorial independence.

Ownership, too, can exert influence directly or subtly through appointments, funding, access, and expectations about what is worth pursuing. A proprietor’s political association is a reason for scrutiny, not proof that every editorial decision is dictated by private interest.

The test lies in patterns: are allies and opponents subjected to comparable questions? Do similar allegations receive similar prominence? Are uncomfortable facts pursued regardless of whom they embarrass?

I describe this possibility as the ‘Ownership Shadow’: the influence proprietorial interests may exert on the news agenda, including through decisions never written down as instructions. A shadow warrants investigation; it does not relieve the investigator of the duty to produce evidence.

The digital environment compounds these pressures. Olorunyomi warned of “high-grade disinformation… an ideological or mythological weapon.” He also described legacy newsrooms as “analogue newsrooms fighting a digital war,” capturing the mismatch between the speed of online manipulation and the capacity of some newsrooms to authenticate what they encounter.

A cropped photograph, misleading caption, or unverified audio recording can travel through social networks before its provenance has been established. When a newspaper reports merely that an allegation is trending, it may lend the claim the credibility of a recognised news organisation.

The report is then circulated as proof that “the media has reported it,” and the rumour returns wearing journalism’s borrowed authority. The 2023 campaign supplied painful illustrations of this hybrid loop.

Consider the controversies surrounding Bola Tinubu’s Chicago State University records and the United States proceedings that resulted in a drug-related settlement. These became enduring features of the campaign conversation, but they raised different questions and should not be collapsed into a single verdict.

The newsroom’s duty was to resist shortcuts: establish the documentary record, explain the legal context, distinguish allegation from finding, and avoid implying that a disputed claim had been conclusively proved simply because it had acquired a headline.

The ‘Yes, Daddy’ audio associated with Peter Obi and Bishop David Oyedepo presented a different but related test. People’s Gazette published the recording; Obi’s camp disputed its authenticity and described it as a deepfake, while the publisher stood by it.

The controversy soon escaped the confines of verification and became a weapon in the wider contest over religion, identity, and political legitimacy. The proper journalistic response was neither automatic acceptance nor reflexive dismissal. It was to establish what could be authenticated, state clearly what remained contested, and resist treating the recording’s circulation as proof of its truth.

A similar caution applied to the allegation circulated against Atiku Abubakar that he had described Southerners as infidels whom Northerners should not support. Social media celebrated and recirculated the claim with extraordinary enthusiasm, but virality is not verification. A responsible report had to establish the source, the full context, the precise wording, and whether reliable evidence supported the attribution.

The clash between ThisDay’s Board of Editors and the APC Presidential Campaign Council over election coverage made the stakes clearer. The dispute was not only about what had been said, but also about who had the authority to define a fair account of the campaign.

Such exchanges can expose legitimate questions about accuracy and balance; they can also become attempts by political actors to discipline unwelcome reporting. The press must neither dismiss every complaint as intimidation nor accept every accusation of bias at face value.

It should answer with records, transparent editorial reasoning, and a willingness to correct demonstrable errors, while refusing to let political displeasure determine what may be investigated or published.

Verification does not end with establishing whether a claim is authentic. It also concerns how the claim is sourced, headlined, and framed. My research notes identify a 21 per cent gap between sensational headlines and the facts contained in the bodies of the stories examined.

Where a headline promises more than the evidence can sustain, readers may absorb the insinuation before reaching the qualification. A headline is not a licence to exaggerate what the story itself cannot establish.

Anonymous sourcing requires equal care. As veteran journalist Nsikak Essien put it, “When you use an anonymous source to attack a candidate’s character, you aren’t reporting; you are laundering propaganda.” Anonymity can be essential when a source faces credible risk, but it must not become a cloak for untested allegations or partisan character assassination.

But I saw a plethora of ‘false juxtapositioning’ and ‘sandwiching’ of reports to justify curious headlines with ‘bullet points, kickers and riders.’ This negates Section 1 of the Nigerian Press Council Code of Professional Ethics, which states that, “the journalist should not use layout, headlines, or pictures to distort the facts or mislead the public”

Hamza Idris described the fact-checking arrangements and internal editorial sessions at Daily Trust, including a fact-check desk that worked round the clock to guard against fake news. Their value lies not merely in their existence on paper but in their consistent application.

Ukeh recalled the editorial maxim, “If in doubt, leave out.” This is not an invitation to avoid difficult stories; it is a demand that publication meet a defensible threshold of evidence.

What, then, should change before 2027? In my doctoral work, I proposed the ACERBATE heuristic as a self-audit for high-stakes election reporting: Analyse Context, Collect Data, Examine Language, Review Sources, Balance Perspectives, Assess Impact, Test Alternatives, and Evaluate Findings.

Used before publication and in post-election reviews, it asks whether a report is adequately evidenced, whether its language exaggerates what is known, whose perspectives are missing, and what the newsroom should learn from its decisions.

I propose, further, a public newsroom scorecard built around transparent criteria: accuracy and corrections, diversity of sources, investigative depth, treatment of candidates, prominence given to competing political voices, and inclusion of communities often neglected in national coverage. Its purpose should be to identify patterns and encourage improvement, not to shame outlets or impose ideological uniformity.

The Nigerian Guild of Editors and the Nigeria Union of Journalists should work with media owners, journalism educators, and independent monitors to develop an Election Reporting Charter well before the campaign intensifies.

It should commit participating newsrooms to verification before velocity; headlines that reflect what stories actually establish; meaningful rights of reply; visible corrections; fair and explainable criteria for candidate coverage; disclosure of relevant conflicts; a firm boundary between advertising and editorial decisions; and a published post-election audit.

These measures will cost money, which is precisely why the economics cannot be treated as an afterthought. More diversified income, reader subscriptions and memberships, carefully protected philanthropic support, and collaborative investigations may reduce dependence on a narrow circle of political or commercial patrons.

No funding model is free of risk; transparency and strong editorial firewalls remain essential. But a newsroom that lacks the means to investigate power is vulnerable even when no proprietor or politician issues an explicit instruction.

As 2027 approaches, the press should be prepared to demonstrate, not merely declare, that its standards can withstand pressure. Can it investigate a political ally as rigorously as an opponent? Can it resist an advertiser’s displeasure, verify a viral allegation before amplifying it, and send reporters beyond the familiar centres of power?

Can it correct a damaging error with the same seriousness with which it published the original claim? Can it make room for citizens whose experiences do not arrive with campaign budgets, political connections, or ready-made press releases?

Ultimately, the press must not be leashed by politicians, proprietors, commercial interests, or fear of public displeasure. Nor should it be let off the hook when it gets the facts wrong, neglects important voices, or allows political theatre to displace public-interest reporting. That is the balance: not to be leashed, and not to be let off the hook.

The Nigerian press owes democracy neither obedience nor a flattering portrait of itself. It owes the public the harder service of establishing what the evidence supports, explaining its decisions when challenged, and correcting its failures without waiting for an opponent to force its hand.

The ink and the ballot are twin guardians of the republic: one records; the other decides. If the ink falters, the ballot is betrayed. If the press becomes the campaign, democracy itself becomes the casualty.

Enough of this teaser. The real deal is in getting ‘Headlines, Deadlines and Election Storylines’…

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by Punch
View on Punch

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…