Business / Nigeria

The reorganisation that changes everything except how work gets done

The reorganisation that changes everything except how work gets done

The execution gap between moving boxes and changing the operating system

The new organisation chart is impressive.

Reporting lines are cleaner. Layers have been removed. Roles renamed. Business units combined. New accountabilities announced. Employees have attended town halls explaining the logic.

Six months later, something feels strangely familiar.

The same decisions still travel through the same few people. The same functions still argue over the same trade-offs. Customers still encounter the same handoffs. Senior leaders still intervene in issues the redesign was meant to solve.

 “Companies reorganise for legitimate reasons: growth, cost pressure, integration, new strategy, technology, succession or simplification. But a reorganisation can be completed successfully as an HR exercise while producing surprisingly little change in how the enterprise actually works.”

The structure changed.

The organisation did not.

That is the uncomfortable possibility behind many reorganisations.

Companies reorganise for legitimate reasons: growth, cost pressure, integration, new strategy, technology, succession or simplification. But a reorganisation can be completed successfully as an HR exercise while producing surprisingly little change in how the enterprise actually works.

“If the boxes move but the decisions, handoffs and behaviours do not, the organisation has been redrawn—not redesigned.”

This matters because restructuring is not free.

It consumes management attention, creates uncertainty, disrupts relationships, slows decisions and can cause good people to leave. Leaders accept those costs because they expect something better: faster decisions, clearer accountability, lower cost, stronger customer ownership or better integration.

If those outcomes do not materialise, the enterprise has paid the disruption cost without capturing the operating benefit.

The problem is that organisation charts are seductive.

They make change visible.

A box can be moved. A reporting line redrawn. A role deleted. A new function can appear on Monday morning.

But execution does not happen inside boxes.

It happens through decisions, interfaces, information, incentives, routines and behaviours.

That is where the operating model lives.

I have seen organisations where the formal structure changed materially but the real decision architecture barely moved. A new business-unit leader existed on paper, but major commercial decisions still returned to the centre. Functions were combined, yet their measures remained conflicting. End-to-end process owners were appointed but lacked authority over the functions controlling the work.

The redesign was visible.

The operating reality was not.

“An organisation chart can change overnight. The operating system underneath it usually does not.”

I describe this as the Structural Change Illusion™: the appearance of organisational transformation created by changing roles, reporting lines or boxes while the decision flows, interfaces and behaviours that determine execution remain substantially unchanged.

The illusion persists because organisations often test whether the new structure has been implemented rather than whether the enterprise now performs differently.

Have the new roles been filled? Have reporting lines changed? Have job descriptions been issued? Have employees been communicated to?

All necessary questions.

But they prove structural completion, not operating change.

The stronger questions are different.

Are decisions being made faster and closer to the work? Have cross-functional handoffs improved? Are accountabilities clearer where value is created? Have duplicated approvals disappeared? Are customer issues resolved with fewer escalations? Have leaders actually stopped doing work that now belongs elsewhere?

A new structure changes where accountability is drawn. A new operating model changes how work moves.

That is why reorganisations often disappoint even when the design logic is sound.

The legacy organisation continues to live through informal power, historical relationships, old performance measures, inherited approval routines and behaviours that survived the announcement.

People quickly discover what really changed.

If a new role supposedly owns an outcome but still needs three old approvals, employees learn that authority did not move. If leaders announce empowerment but continue reversing decisions, judgement has not moved. If functions are told to collaborate but remain rewarded for conflicting outcomes, the old system still governs behaviour.

The organisation chart may say “new”.

The operating signals still say “old”.

For CEOs, the test of a reorganisation should therefore extend beyond span, layers and cost. Leadership should be explicit about which decisions will move, which interfaces will change and which enterprise outcomes should improve because the redesign occurred.

For CHROs, organisation design cannot stop at roles and reporting lines. Performance measures, incentives, capability and leadership behaviour must reinforce the new architecture or the old organisation will quietly reconstitute itself inside the new one.

For boards, restructuring benefits should be examined like any other investment. If the business case promised faster decisions, lower overhead, stronger accountability or better customer outcomes, those benefits should eventually be visible in operating evidence—not merely a completed chart.

Three ideas are worth remembering.

A new structure is not evidence of a new operating model.

The organisation people experience is defined less by where they report than by how decisions, information and accountability actually move.

And the test of a reorganisation is not whether everyone knows where they sit. It is whether the enterprise now works differently.

The execution question:

If you compared your organisation six months before and six months after its last reorganisation, which important decisions, handoffs and behaviours actually changed—and which simply survived inside a new chart?

Akin Monehin is the best-selling author of Execution Is a Lie and Managing Partner of Praxis Execution Advisory. He has worked across more than 10 countries, with experience spanning British Airways, Virgin Atlantic, Nigeria LNG and Shell, where he was a member of the Shell Deepwater Executive Leadership Team, in charge of Business Transformation. He advises CEOs, executive teams and public institutions on translating strategy into results, strengthening execution capability and converting organisational ambition into measurable performance and value. www.theakinmonehin.com

Add BusinessDay as a preferred source on Google Follow BusinessDay on Google News

Share this story WhatsApp Facebook X
Originally published by BusinessDay
View on BusinessDay

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading the next story…