- As South Africans vote in local government elections, failing services, crime and unemployment have left many communities desperate for change.
- In Brazil’s Maré favelas, where armed groups and police violence threaten residents’ safety, a community organisation is showing how people can take charge of their future.
- Redes da Maré helps young people get into university, women escape abusive relationships and people who use drugs get support — tackling problems that policing alone cannot solve.
- The lesson for South Africa’s voters? Better politicians matter, but lasting change also needs organised communities that demand services, create opportunities and hold leaders accountable.
As South Africans head to the polls in local government elections today, hoping for something better from those who run our towns and cities, Brazil offers a reminder that change is possible — but that it takes more than a change of political leadership.
The mood here at home is hardly one of optimism: failing municipal services, toxic rubbish dumps, violent crime with 60 murders a day, joblessness with half of young people up to the age of 24 unemployed, militant groups barring immigrants from public health facilities, and daily water interruptions in cities like Durban and Johannesburg. It leaves many communities feeling frustrated — particularly by empty promises made by politicians every five years.
But 8 000 kilometres away, in Brazil, a different political story is unfolding.
On 25 October, Lula da Silva secured another term as president, winning a closely contested election. For many poorer Brazilians, particularly those who have long felt excluded from the country’s economic progress, his victory has renewed hope.
Lula built his political reputation on fighting poverty and inequality. During his previous term, poverty in Brazil declined, helped by improved employment and government social support programmes. His return has raised expectations that the poorest will remain a priority.
Earlier this year, during the International Aids Conference in Rio de Janeiro, Bhekisisa visited Maré, a group of favelas (informal settlements) that are home to about 140 000 people. Here, armed groups control parts of the neighbourhood, while police raids regularly disrupt daily life. Residents are often caught between the two.
But Maré also tells another story: of communities refusing to give up.
We met Carolina Dias, who works for Redes da Maré, a community organisation fighting for residents’ rights. Its work goes beyond challenging police violence. It helps young people access university, provides women with skills to start businesses and leave abusive relationships, and offers lasting support to people who use drugs or live on the streets.
Its approach is simple: services, development and safety. Safer communities need more than policing. They need opportunities, functioning services and people who have a say in decisions affecting their lives
There are obvious differences between Brazil and South Africa, and a favela is not the same as a South African informal settlement. But the challenges of inequality, crime and communities feeling forgotten are familiar.
The lesson from Maré is that politicians alone cannot deliver lasting change. Change needs communities to organise, participate and hold those in power accountable.
Lula’s victory may have offered Brazil’s poorest a renewed sense of possibility. For South Africans, today could be an opportunity to demand the same: a future in which where you live doesn’t determine how safe you are, what opportunities you have or whether your basic needs are met.
In this reel, Bhekisisa’s TV news editor Anna-Maria van Niekerk breaks down the lessons from Maré and reflects on her visit to Rio’s favelas in July this year.
View this post on InstagramA post shared by Bhekisisa Health Journalism (@bhekisisa.health)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.